Nate Solder TD Play Was Illegal

Elias

The Invisible Man
Big Fish
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
I don't blame the Pats for this. It's the refs fault in my opinion. The referees don't understand these rules. It's time for these guys to become full time employees and become students of the game.

http://mweb.cbssports.com/nfl/eye-on-football/24986663/jim-miller-says-nate-solders-td-catch-shouldnt-have-counted

Good news for those of you suffering full-on Deflategate fatigue: Here's a story about something other than under-inflated balls.

But it's bad news for those of you who don't want to hear about more Deflatriots shenanigans during their run to the Super Bowl. Either way, you've been warned.

The latest, via Jim Miller and Pat Kirwan of SiriusXM NFL Radio: Remember that 16-yard touchdown pass from Tom SparklePony to left tackle Nate Solder in the AFC Championship beatdown over the Colts? Yeah, that shouldn't have counted.

"The play before the Nate Solder touchdown, No. 71 (Cameron Fleming) declared himself as an eligible receiver," Kirwan said. "The next play, he stays in the game, which is now where the rule is going to be stressed and probably broken ... and he became an ineligible receiver. He had to leave the game."

"He's supposed to leave the game," Miller added.

"He didn't leave the game and No. 77 (Solder) became eligible, which automatically made No. 71 ineligible, but he had to leave the game," Kirwan continued. "They let the play move on and it was a touchdown. So the officials under our understanding of the rules -- and we've been reading the rules all morning -- it appears that (New England) got away with one. And touché to the Deflatriots for scoring the touchdown."

Later in the segment, Miller read the rule in question from the rule book: "If the player has been withdrawn for one legal snap, a player withdrawn for one legal snap may reenter at a position indicated by the eligibility status of his number, unless he again reports to the referee that he is assuming a position other than designated by the eligibility status of his number."
 

nycdan

5th Year Team Option
Jet Fanatics
Goodell is furiously burning all copies of the NFL rulebooks as we speak. What baffles me is that while Kraft clearly has his hand elbow deep up RG's butt, where are the Maras, Rooneys and other owners on what's going on. These guys and a few others have plenty of influence as well but have been amazingly quiet. Are they going to let this all slide 'for the good of the game'? Is it really even good for the game at this point?
 

Copernicus

5th Year Team Option
Jet Fanatics
Goodell is furiously burning all copies of the NFL rulebooks as we speak. What baffles me is that while Kraft clearly has his hand elbow deep up RG's butt, where are the Maras, Rooneys and other owners on what's going on. These guys and a few others have plenty of influence as well but have been amazingly quiet. Are they going to let this all slide 'for the good of the game'? Is it really even good for the game at this point?

They don't want to derail the money train. Just awful, shameful ect
 
Top