Wow, I hate to agree with you but I guess I have to. Don't know anything about any of the other QBs except Winston and Mariota. Winston is a no drainer he's ready day one. Mariota I was very skeptical about but my frustration with Geno I was willing to draft Mariota and move on. At least put Mariota and Geno in competition and see what happens. What I'm really pissed at is the phila trade falling through with Foles and the multiple draft picks.
Anyway, so here we are stuck with Geno and only can hope he has developed enough to help this team. We all can see if this team keeps building the way they are in FA, plus you add in the draft picks they will be ready to make the playoffs this year. Only question is can the QB hold his own and not mess it up? Guess well see because Geno scares the shit out of me. I'm very hopeful he is ready and your right, he has shown flashes but shown more flashes if the negative also. I'm just hoping he steps up because I want Fitzgerald being that insurance policy just in case and not what were depending on period.
It's just my opinion, nothing more. I would encourage you not to be swayed but what I say or anyone else for that matter. Take a look at the game film yourself and draw your own conclusions.
www.draftbreakdown.com shows full games of all prospects play by play and it gives you a better idea of the prospect's game overall.
After watching all the top pass rush prospects, I liked Odighizuwa as much as I did the top prospects in Gregory, Fowler and Beasley. At the same time, I found Shane Ray to be choppy, one-directional with lateral movement lacking. I think he has attained his sacks from his overall strength and pursuit. His strength may not overwhelm pro OT's and I think his limited athleticism will keep him from being a high sack guy. Just my opinion.
And I formed my opinions on watching the QB's as well - all of them. I encourage you to do the same. You'll probably have differing conclusions from mine, or not.
In seeing this last year, I felt that Beckham was far and away the best prospect at WR. I think the tape is very telling. He had the best combination of route running and suddenness with an uncanny ability to high-point the ball. Great athleticism and hops and always was around the ball.
I love Amari Cooper at WR but not White. I love Winston but not Mariota.
But I digress. Take a look when you get a chance.