from all accounts, Not too many people do more charity work and is nicer than Tim Tebow...I still don't want him on our team. It's hard for me to separate the good guy story from the football side on a NFL chat board.
To your point, it's is nice he's a good guy.
Yeah but 55, he's a good guy. You can't cut him....
This kind of emotional struggle is found in all aspects of life. People are almost programmed to overlook any faults if they think someone's a "good guy". I've seen this on other boards with regard to Willie Colon who was a penalty machine and missed blocks everywhere yet posters (fans) would defend him to the end blaming everyone except him for any issues and pointing out what a "good guy" he was. "He's GREAT for the locker room". Okay. On the flip side, everyone except myself was not judging Revis for being a good business man. Everyone despised him for being "greedy".
This goes on in the professional world as well as studies have shown for decades that being a popular person counts at least as much if not more than your skills. This kind of mentality makes businesses and teams weaker and is why fans can't understand the so-called "cruelty" of such popular players being forced out.
This is what you're up against here 55. How dare you not gloss over Sudfeld's shortcomings and point out his deficiencies. You're not human!
We're seeing the same rhetoric being ratcheted up for Wilk. We did to a large degree for Rex, didn't we? I did. I love the guy and wanted badly for him to succeed here. In the end, Woody had to let him go. It was the right decision. Difficult but correct.
All that said, I think you are obsessing too much on one or two plays for him. Just the same, I don't think his chances are good to make this team, nor Cumberland's after this season. I think the Jets will get a TE who can actually block and then flash receiving skills. There are a few in this draft - watch for our 4th rounder here.