Best Guitarist

U

ucrenegade

Guest
Having computer issues today I will post my list sometime today.
 

Fudbutter

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
Skin beaters:
Neil Peart
MIke Portnoy
Terry Bozzio---nice call, fud!
Mark Zonder
Mike Mangini
Carl Palmer
Cozy Powell(RIP)
Dave Lombardo
Mitch Mitchell(RIP)
Gavin Harrison

and of course: Bonzo!

Excellent list there WM!

A zillion points for knowing Gavin Harrison. Missed Porcupine Tree when they toured but started gathering their CD's a few years ago (yes some of us still use CD's :))

Wasn't familiar with Warlord's music, so I have to check out Zonder. Any suggested CD's?

BTW: we're stumbling to over 20 posts in this thread and we still haven't done best electric violinist
 

Fudbutter

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
Forgot one important guitarist:
Alan Holdsworth

And as far as electric violinists go:
Jerry Goodman
John Blair
Eddie Jobson
Jean-Luc Ponty
Michael Urbaniak

that's all I got
 

The Wicker Man

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
Excellent list there WM!

A zillion points for knowing Gavin Harrison. Missed Porcupine Tree when they toured but started gathering their CD's a few years ago (yes some of us still use CD's :))

Wasn't familiar with Warlord's music, so I have to check out Zonder. Any suggested CD's?

BTW: we're stumbling to over 20 posts in this thread and we still haven't done best electric violinist
Cool, another Porcupine Tree fan! Great band!

I more familiar with Zonder's work with Fates Warning. " Pleasant Shade of a Gray", Parallels, Perfect Symmetry, No Exit, X....

Electric Violinist----that's easy-Mark Wood(TSO)


Fates Warning:


 

Fudbutter

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
Forgot about Wood. Saw him open for Vai a bunch of years ago. Did a knockout version of UK's Caesar's Palace Blues. Did major justice to Jobson's playing. Of course he's talented, he's from Long Island !

UK was a band full of guys on our best list. Wetton-Holdsworth-Bruford-Jobson at first and Wetton-Jobson-Bozzio as a trio. Only had two studio albums.

Will check out Fates Warning. The problem with metal is that there were so many great bands that it is hard to know it all.
 
D

Dickkotite

Guest
I hate these threads....
The two best are not even for debate
1. Hendrix
2. Van halen


Then theres a drop off.
In no particular order:
Randy rhoads
Robert fripp
Steve howe

Then theres another drop off...

That is all. Now you know. Lock this thread please
 

Fudbutter

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
I hate these threads....
The two best are not even for debate
1. Hendrix
2. Van halen


Then theres a drop off.
In no particular order:
Randy rhoads
Robert fripp
Steve howe

Then theres another drop off...

That is all. Now you know. Lock this thread please


nice, Mr. Rhoads joins the party with his Jacksons and a custom Flying Vee


You still have drummers, bassists and electric violinists to list though :)
 

johnnysd

5th Year Team Option
Jet Fanatics
Have to add in Andres Segovia to the list. Classical musicians are important too and he was incredibly good, and as George Harrison once said a good part of the reason guitar became popular.

On the electric side, no love for Mark Knopfler? Chet Atkins was pretty innovative in country styles as well. Mark and Chets album neck to neck is pretty great.
 

Oraelo

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
I
Bass:
Steve Harris
Geddy Lee
Billy Sheehan
Les Claypool-this guy's insane
Geezer Butler
John Entwistle
John Myung
Dave Ellefson
John Wetton
Chris Squire
I saw les claypool at the gathering of the vibes years ago doing a folk acoustic set. Blew my mind.
 

Oraelo

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
Skin beaters:
Neil Peart
MIke Portnoy
Terry Bozzio---nice call, fud!
Mark Zonder
Mike Mangini
Carl Palmer
Cozy Powell(RIP)
Dave Lombardo
Mitch Mitchell(RIP)
Gavin Harrison

and of course: Bonzo!
I have to add Scott Rockenfield from Queensryche.
 

The Wicker Man

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
Vocalist:
Ronnie James Dio(RIP)-Elf-Rainbow-Black Sabbath-Dio
Bruce Dickinson-Iron Maiden
Robin Zander(underrated imo)-Cheap Trick
Mike Baker(RIP)-Shadow Gallery
Stefan Zell-Wolverine-a new favorite of mine
John Bush-Armored Saint-Anthrax
Zak Stevens-Savatage-Circle II Circle
Roy Kahn-Kamelot-Conception
John Arch-Fates Warning-Arch/Matheos
Tim "Ripper" Owens-Judas Priest-Iced Earth-Charred Walls of the Damned
Matt Barlow-Iced Earth-Ashes of Ares
Ian Gillan-Deep Purple
Keith Sudano-Eternity X
Mike Howe-Heretic-Metal Church
Warrel Dane-Sanctuary-Nevermore
Russell Allen-Symphony X-Adrenaline Mob
Phil Lynott(RIP)-Thin Lizzy
Phil Moog-UFO
Freddie Mercury(RIP)-Queen
Eric A.K.-Flotsam and Jetsam
Women:
Natalie Merchant-10,000 Maniacs
Lana Lane
Sharon den Adel-Within Temptation
 

Fudbutter

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
Vocalist:
Ronnie James Dio(RIP)-Elf-Rainbow-Black Sabbath-Dio
Bruce Dickinson-Iron Maiden
Robin Zander(underrated imo)-Cheap Trick
Mike Baker(RIP)-Shadow Gallery
Stefan Zell-Wolverine-a new favorite of mine
John Bush-Armored Saint-Anthrax
Zak Stevens-Savatage-Circle II Circle
Roy Kahn-Kamelot-Conception
John Arch-Fates Warning-Arch/Matheos
Tim "Ripper" Owens-Judas Priest-Iced Earth-Charred Walls of the Damned
Matt Barlow-Iced Earth-Ashes of Ares
Ian Gillan-Deep Purple
Keith Sudano-Eternity X
Mike Howe-Heretic-Metal Church
Warrel Dane-Sanctuary-Nevermore
Russell Allen-Symphony X-Adrenaline Mob
Phil Lynott(RIP)-Thin Lizzy
Phil Moog-UFO
Freddie Mercury(RIP)-Queen
Eric A.K.-Flotsam and Jetsam
Women:
Natalie Merchant-10,000 Maniacs
Lana Lane
Sharon den Adel-Within Temptation

Not much for vocals but I think that you have to add Peter Gabriel to the list.

Then put that list aside and write down three names for a very special list ... Janis Joplin, Billie Holiday and Aretha Franklin .
 

Oraelo

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
Not much for vocals but I think that you have to add Peter Gabriel to the list.

Then put that list aside and write down three names for a very special list ... Janis Joplin, Billie Holiday and Aretha Franklin .

I was going to say that he missed Janis, but you nailed it with the big three Fud. Those three have no comparisons in today's music.
 

The Wicker Man

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
Vocals can be an acquired taste, having said that, I never cared for JJ....or Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen(who I really can't stand) and others....but I like Tom Petty.
 

Fudbutter

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
Vocals can be an acquired taste, having said that, I never cared for JJ....or Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen(who I really can't stand) and others....but I like Tom Petty.

well you still have to put all three on the best lyricist lists (I guess sooner or later we'll get to best tuba players :)

Also add Peter Sinfield, Keith Reid, John Lennon, Paul Simon and Richard Palmer-James plus I'm sure a hundred more (would Leonard Cohen count?)
 

Fudbutter

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
I was going to say that he missed Janis, but you nailed it with the big three Fud. Those three have no comparisons in today's music.

I wonder what Janis would have done if she lived but they were getting her off the blues and making her more commercially viable, so it might have been one of those things like Genesis where only the early stuff is worthwhile.

However that's like saying what Namath would have done if he never hurt his knee at Alabama. Really need someone to make string theory practical to we can access the alternate universes t see :)
 

Oraelo

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
I wonder what Janis would have done if she lived but they were getting her off the blues and making her more commercially viable, so it might have been one of those things like Genesis where only the early stuff is worthwhile.

However that's like saying what Namath would have done if he never hurt his knee at Alabama. Really need someone to make string theory practical to we can access the alternate universes t see :)
Since we are going there I want to find the universe with the group that has a rhythm section of Jaco and bonzo, Hendrix and Rhodes as the guitarists and Janis up front on the mic. (And for my own personal satisfaction, Jerry Bear helpin out with the rhythms on vocals and guitar.)
Not sure my brain could handle so much awesome on one stage.
 
Top