The NFL Competition Committee will be talking about replay on pass interference penalties

Elias

The Invisible Man
Big Fish
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
The NFL Competition Committee will be talking about replay on pass interference penalties

How do you feel about instant replay on interference plays? Also should it just be a 15 yard penalty or at the spot of the penalty?

Giants owner John Mara intrigued by PI replay - NFL.com

The pass interference that wasn't during the Wild Card battle between the Dallas Cowboys and Detroit Lions spurned a lot of debate about reviewing such calls in the future.

The NFL's Competition Committee will discuss the issue this offseason.

One member of the committee, Giants co-owner John Mara, hasn't been in favor of reviewing penalty calls in the past, but might be changing his mind.

"I've always been an opponent of it, but I have to tell you, I'm starting to think a little different about it," he said Wednesday on WFAN radio. "It's such a huge penalty and I'm starting to change my mind about that.

"I know that's something we're going to discuss at the competition committee starting in February and I'm looking forward to that because I think the time has come to, not only have that discussion and that debate, but to really think about a change in that rule. The replay was implemented in order to try to correct the major calls in games, to get the big call right, and they're not too many calls that are bigger than a defensive pass interference."

The committee will make a recommendation to NFL owners who will vote on the issue.
"You have to keep in mind, it takes 24 votes to get anything accomplished in the NFL and that sometimes is a difficult task, but I would not be surprised if we added to the reviewable plays," Mara said.

Coming from a committee member and an influential owner that's a heavy statement for those in favor of adding reviews on interference calls.
 
S

sg3

Guest
Illegal contact..eliminate..it's either holding or nothing

Def holding...5 yards, no auto first down

PI ..10 yards no.auto.first down

Roughing the passer..no intent. no.call..

accidentally brushing Tammi's helmet or shin, no call

And finally

15 yard unsportsmanlike conduct to any wide receiver, tight end, running back or quarterback who waves his arms wildly after an incomplete pass trying to draw a PI flag....like embellishing in hockey.

Give the defense half a fighting chance, for godsake
 

sect313

Day 1 Prospect
Jet Fanatics
very good idea, just too many times it looks like PI but is not. But keep it as spot of foul penalty
 

Elias

The Invisible Man
Big Fish
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
very good idea, just too many times it looks like PI but is not. But keep it as spot of foul penalty

I agree but my only concern would be if it will slow down the game. I just wish the ref didn't have to go under the hood and that someone from the top already had the call reviewed, they just check in with him and then move on. No need for the theatrics of the ref walking underneath the hood lol
 
S

sg3

Guest
I agree but my only concern would be if it will slow down the game. I just wish the ref didn't have to go under the hood and that someone from the top already had the call reviewed, they just check in with him and then move on. No need for the theatrics of the ref walking underneath the hood lol
The way it is done in NHL, NCAA and even MLB

Of course, it would cut down on Ed Horsesass TV face time, speech making and free advertising for his real lawyer job
 

Bigmoe

Happily Confused
The Mod Squad
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
Illegal contact..eliminate..it's either holding or nothing

Def holding...5 yards, no auto first down

PI ..10 yards no.auto.first down

Roughing the passer..no intent. no.call..

accidentally brushing Tammi's helmet or shin, no call

And finally

15 yard unsportsmanlike conduct to any wide receiver, tight end, running back or quarterback who waves his arms wildly after an incomplete pass trying to draw a PI flag....like embellishing in hockey.

Give the defense half a fighting chance, for godsake

Agree on all counts
They are ruining the game, after all big plays the first thing I look for is a flag. Terrible
For the younger guys this is when it all started to change

1977
A 16-game regular season, 4-game preseason was adopted to begin in 1978.

A second wild-card team was adopted for the playoffs beginning in 1978, with the wild-card teams to play each other and the winners advancing to a round of eight postseason series.

Rule changes were adopted to open up the passing game and to cut down on injuries.

Defenders were permitted to make contact with eligible receivers only once; the head slap was outlawed; offensive linemen were prohibited from thrusting their hands to an opponent's neck, face, or head; and wide receivers were prohibited from clipping, even in the legal clipping zone.
 

mykcuz

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
Pass interference must be spot of foul, otherwise if I'm a defender and I can't defense the reception on a50 yard bomb, I'd just tackle the wr before the ball arrives. I just saved 35 yards on the play.
 
S

sg3

Guest
Pass interference must be spot of foul, otherwise if I'm a defender and I can't defense the reception on a50 yard bomb, I'd just tackle the wr before the ball arrives. I just saved 35 yards on the play.
It isn't in college and that rule works much better

It reduces games being decided by ticky tack calls on 50 yard uncatchable desperation hail mary heaves with seconds remaining.

It also reduces the impact of soccer style pro actors like Gronkowski and girly men QBS like Tammy waving her arms after each incomplete pass to be handed a free long gainer

10 yards, no auto first down eliminates this sham of a call
 

Teacht79

Day 3 Prospect
Jet Fanatics
Pass interference must be spot of foul, otherwise if I'm a defender and I can't defense the reception on a50 yard bomb, I'd just tackle the wr before the ball arrives. I just saved 35 yards on the play.

Definitely agree with this point
 

mykcuz

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
You still don't address the intentional pi, imagine dez Bryant open in the end zone catching the game winning ball, and the defender throws him to the ground before the ball gets there. That's Busch league bra
 

mykcuz

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
It isn't in college and that rule works much better

It reduces games being decided by ticky tack calls on 50 yard uncatchable desperation hail mary heaves with seconds remaining.

It also reduces the impact of soccer style pro actors like Gronkowski and girly men QBS like Tammy waving her arms after each incomplete pass to be handed a free long gainer

10 yards, no auto first down eliminates this sham of a call
No offense but completely disagree that's like reducing murder convictions by making some murder legal.

Not worried about length of game, worried about producing a good product and getting the call right.
 

mykcuz

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
Make flopping and calling for penalty unsportsmanlike, that solves gronk, not changing how football is played
 
Top