Poll: Worst decision of the 1st round

[BlindsideD'Brick]

Some suggestions:

1.) Cleveland (the Factory of Sadness) passing on Sam Darnold for Mayfield

2.) Cleveland passing on Bradley Chubb for Denzel Ward

3.) The Raiders taking Kolton Miller

4.) The Cowboys taking LB Leighton Vander Esch

5.) The Seahawks taking RB Rashaad Penny

6.) The Steelers taking S Terrell Edmunds

 

[SackExchange]

For me, it's Ward. Though a case could be made for the Pats and Wynn. I love him as a lineman in general, and hate him as a possible LT.

 

[cheaterhater]

For me, it's Ward. Though a case could be made for the Pats and Wynn. I love him as a lineman in general, and hate him as a possible LT.

don't worry. Donte scarnechia will have him playing left tackle like he's been there forever and the boy wonder brady makes everyone around him better(sarcasm)

 

[hobson54]

what about the saints giving up a future 1st to trade up for davenport?

 

[cheaterhater]

Browns should have taken Barkley or Chubb or Nelson at 1and QB at 4

 

[gmf1369]

The Seahawks taking RB Rashaad Penny - (rated 3rd round RB)

he was at best a second round guy but damn. that was 60 or spots too high

 

[Flyboys89]

For me this one is obvious and I even laughed out loud when the pick was made..

6) Steelers - Terrel Edmunds. Got to be the worst pick of the round by far. Pro Football Focus has him as the 20th ranked safety prospect in this years class ,that is the TWENTIETH at his POSITION in this safety class. The pick was so bad I was quietly asking if they maybe didn't realize the bills drafted Trumain Edmunds (same last name) and pitt didn't realize it and by accident took the safety thinking they just drafted the LB haha

 

[SackExchange]

what about the saints giving up a future 1st to trade up for davenport?

That was a head-scratcher, as well.

 

[maxmet]

Ward

if you want Ward, trade down and get something and take him lower

 

[Xmarco]

I think Penny will be a great pick up
Cowboys needed LB Sean Lee always hurt and the other left in FA

 

[Xmarco]

My vote would be Gruden and the RayDuhs

 

[Seaver41]

what about the saints giving up a future 1st to trade up for davenport?

Bingo.......horrible move

 

[jets82]

Pick # 1: Mayfield will turn to be the next Breez and R. Wilson combined. Which will be a phenomenal number one pick but not likely to happen or Doug Flutie at worst and that will not be good at all for a number one pick. Huge difference so I go this way.

 

[Innocenti]

The Giants drafting Barkley

 

[Green Jets & Ham]

Definitely Terrell Edmunds to the Steelers in RD 1

I didn't even think he had a 2nd RD Grade.

His brother Tremaine, OTOH, is a wrecking machine and I was pissed when the Bills traded up for him at 16

 

[Innocenti]

I should elaborate on what I wrote. The Giants have a 37 year-old qb who has had a penchant for turning the ball over even on his best days. They had like 3 wins last season and they were sitting on the second pick overall in a qb heavy draft. The elephant in the room was the qb situation. So they draft a RB to help him. The QB is the problem and not the lack of an RB. The first RB selected in a draft rarely reaches the superbowl. Since the merger, there have been 3 or 4 out of 48 and I think 2 reached with different teams. Bottom line: a successful Barkley wont fix the qb problems and probably wont lead the Giants to the superbowl.

I think the Browns made a good pick in Mayfield. But personality wise he seems risky.