I'm definitely warming up to the idea of taking Josh Rosen. We can only hope the Giants decide to take Barkley or Nelson with the #2 pick and not take a QB this year. Out of Allen and Mayfield, I would prefer Allen, not because I think he's better today, but I think could be better down the road. I share the same worries with Allen as everyone else does here - is he Hackenberg all over again? But it's hard to ignore his skill set - and he seems like a good kid with a good head on his shoulders, just like Hackenberg. If we took Mayfield, he'd have to win me over with his conduct on and off the field. I think he can play the position, but we don't need an immature jerk leading the franchise. If he's grown up, and he proves it over time, I'd be fine with it. My first choice right now would be Rosen, assuming of course that Darnold is off the board.