Sorting out Jets' complicated QB situation not as easy as 1-2-3

gmf1369

Jack of All Trades
Big Fish
The Mod Squad
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
i


ESPN -- Now that Bryce Petty is gone, released Thursday in an expected move, the New York Jets are down to four quarterbacks. Four is a conventional number for this time of the year, but there's nothing conventional about their quarterback situation.

A lot can happen in the next few months in terms of the starting job and backup roles. A ranking of the various permutations for Week 1, from most likely to least likely:

1. Josh McCown, Sam Darnold -- The Jets haven't gone with only two since 2013 (Geno Smith and Matt Simms), but it's the best approach for the sake of Darnold's development -- and that's what matters most. It wouldn't make sense if he's buried at the bottom of a three-man depth chart. If healthy, Teddy Bridgewater could be trade bait if he plays well in the preseason. If not, he can be released with only a $500,000 cap hit. Adios, Christian Hackenberg.

2. McCown, Bridgewater, Darnold -- We'll call this the traditional setup because coach Todd Bowles always has carried at least three. The upside is they'd have plenty of veteran insurance, not a bad way to go when you consider the injury histories for McCown and Bridgewater. The downside: If Darnold emerges as the starter, the Jets would be spending $16 million for two veteran backups. Of course, they could carry Bridgewater with the hope of moving him before the midseason trading deadline. Another team is bound to lose a quarterback along the way.

3. Bridgewater, Darnold -- Before his devastating knee injury in 2016, Bridgewater was a solid game manager (17-11 for the Minnesota Vikings). If his surgically repaired knee obliges, he conceivably could crush the preseason and beat out McCown. At 25, Bridgewater certainly has more upside. If they cut McCown, 38, they'd have to eat a $5 million guarantee (half his base salary). Another factor to consider: Darnold would lose the ideal mentor -- and the team would lose a leader -- if McCown is jettisoned.

4. McCown, Darnold, Hackenberg -- If general manager Mike Maccagnan gets stubborn and refuses to admit his Hackenberg mistake, he could give the former second-round pick another shot as a third-stringer. But what's the point? It's time to cut bait. Plus, it would be unfair to Hackenberg. After two years as the No. 1 project, he'd be the forgotten man in the quarterback room.

5. Bridgewater, Darnold, Hackenberg -- See above.

6. McCown, Bridgewater, Darnold, Hackenberg -- The Jets did the four-quarterback thing in 2016, and it didn't benefit anybody. There's no need to recreate that cumbersome dynamic.
 

gmf1369

Jack of All Trades
Big Fish
The Mod Squad
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
$5 M guaranteed if cut only save $5 M of $10 M salary... He'd be one expensive QB Coach... Plus he would have to retire, to be hired as QB Coach...

Have to suspect the battle is between Teddy Bridgewater & Christian Hackenberg for the 3rd spot but it is possible that if they can not choose between those two that McCown could be on the chopping block...
 

TebowCan'tThrow

Supersize!
The Mod Squad
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
$5 M guaranteed if cut only save $5 M of $10 M salary... He'd be one expensive QB Coach... Plus he would have to retire, to be hired as QB Coach...

Have to suspect the battle is between Teddy Bridgewater & Christian Hackenberg for the 3rd spot but it is possible that if they can not choose between those two that McCown could be on the chopping block...

If they can't choose between Hackenberg and pretty much any stiff in the league then that shows incompetence. He is garbage. Needs to be cut or placed on PS.
 
Last edited:

jets82

Curious George
Jet Fanatics
Wow, this is a real interesting topic (thread) and no idea how it will pan out. My hope is Darnold is ready to start game one and he actually does. This way it doesn’t matter who’s behind him. Well I can’t necessarily say that. It would be better for McCown to be here to mentor Darnold through this one season. Whether as a back up or starter. Hack ofcourse gets cut and Bridgewater I guess it’s all up to his leg. He’s healthy then he stays or gets traded. He’s not and I guess he gets cut. Hard facts but reality is all about hard facts.
 

butterscotch

Jets/Cards
Jets Global
What is the story on Bridgewaters leg long term? I mean I see us with two chances at a 6.5 or better QB? As far as 5ive million dollar coach so be it. Pay the money...Geez I will chip in $5.00
 
Last edited:

NCgreen12

Pro Bowl Alternate
Jet Fanatics
Ideally they want Bridgewater to show some ability in preseason for one reason - to trade him if a contending team's QB goes down. It will be McCown (who Bowles loves) and Darnold who will probably get his start half way through the season...
 

BlindsideD'Brick

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
Ideally they want Bridgewater to show some ability in preseason for one reason - to trade him if a contending team's QB goes down. It will be McCown (who Bowles loves) and Darnold who will probably get his start half way through the season...

Pretty much how I see it. In an ideal world, Darnold is ready week one. But we don’t live in an ideal world. Darnold should not be rushed. Put him in at the right time. Unless Teddy shows something in training camp or preseason, it’s gotta be McCown.

Regardless, I believe the QB situation is in good shape.
 

hobson54

Transition Tagged
Jet Fanatics
Is hack eligible to go onto the practice squad? seems like a potential solution although obviously if another team wanted to give him a roster spot, they would lose him.
 

jetgreen13

founding JFU member..
Jet Fanatics
i read somewhere else, hackenberg had an off season program working on his throwing motion.. when bowles was asked about it, he had no idea..

looks very much like the jets will cut a 2nd rounder before he takes an NFL regular season snap..

very gholston-ish..
 
Last edited:

NewMFS62

Weeb's Mentor
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
I'd rather have Bridgewater with one good leg than Hackbenberg with no good arm.
Later
 
Top