Agree that Idzik and injuries forced Ryan to scramble in the secondary, but Ryan compounded the problem by playing Antonio Allen at CB and putting Pryor in an uncomfortable position. That left them with a keystone cops situation in the back 4. Thankfully that is not the situation this year.
That's a classic Monday Morning QB response. Since when do you know more than the Head Coach? The guy that is intimately familiar with his own team? You're also essentially questioning his defensive pedigree. As if somehow you know more about the athletic abilities of some players and schemes more so? Like you've been spending time in the locker room with all of these players.
That's ridiculous. The most obvious and common sense answer is to look at the talent level of the team. John Idzik f*cked Rex Ryan. He knew damn well what Rex needed to run his schemes. We've all seen it. We saw for years how Tanny tried to get Rex two corners that could defend "on an island". He wanted to bring the house. John Idzik did NOTHING to help Rex Ryan with that situation. In fact, he COMPOUNDED the issue by never replacing Dmitri Patterson after he was cur for missing a game. Rex Ryan was forced to try and make chicken salad out of chicken sh*t his last 2 years in town and that is a fact.
Rex Ryan had also just come off his coaching campaign of his coaching career. He guided the 2013 Jets team to 8-8 when they had almost NO talent on offense at all. That was a coaching feat for the ages.
Now if you wanted to criticize and say his teams were undisciplined and drew too many penalties or his defenses never generated any turnovers? That would be hard to argue. History proves that out. But to sit there and pretend as though you more know more than a guy like Rex Ryan with NO evidence to back it up, just pure speculation and a bad attempt at reading between the lines is pure arrogance.
THIS season makes the point even more visible. Do you think Todd Bowles would keep everyone in their native positions if MacCagnan hadn't added Darrelle Revis, Antonio Cromartie, Marcus Gilchrist, and Buster Skrine to the picture? Todd Bowles has great talent to work with. Rex Ryan had NOTHING. He'll, he didn't even have Dee Milliner, the guy that plays good corner when he's in there, but is a bum that can't stay on the field. Another brilliant move by Idzik.