Jets' quarterback competition gets weird ... and TB clams up

gmf1369

Jack of All Trades
Big Fish
The Mod Squad
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
i

FLORHAM PARK, N.J. -- For the second straight day, Christian Hackenbergand Bryce Petty shared the majority of the quarterback reps, with Josh McCownreduced to a bit role on Wednesday. This is a curious way to conduct a competition, considering there's only one preseason game remaining for the starters.

Predictably, New York Jets coach Todd Bowles offered no insight, leaving us to decipher the strategy. It could be one of two things:

1. Bowles knows what McCown can do and wants to give Hackenberg and Petty as many reps as possible, perhaps even letting them play most of the game Saturday night against the New York Giants. The downside to this approach is that McCown will get shortchanged, which could come back to bite them if he's the Week 1 starter, as expected. He's a heady player, but even smart guys need game reps. So far, McCown has taken only seven snaps in the preseason.

2. Bowles is keeping his options open. He hasn't tipped his hand, refusing to give the edge to anyone. If you take his words at face value, it's still an open competition, which would mean Hackenberg still has a chance to be the Week 1 starter. That would be an all-time upset, considering the way he played last week in Detroit. Hackenberg would have to be lights-out against a very good Giants defense to warrant consideration, but don't be surprised if he gets first-team work in the game.

It doesn't have to be this confusing, of course, but the Jets send mixed messages. Bowles said the coaching staff won't decide this week's starter until Thursday night. Asked if all three will play, he said, "We'll sit down and talk about it."

Is there a chance Hackenberg could start?

"We've got to sit down and talk about it," Bowles said.

Any chance he'd rest McCown on Saturday night?

"We'll sit down and talk about it," he said. "It's still early."

On Wednesday, Hackenberg led the way with 19 reps, followed by Petty (15) and McCown (nine). A look at their day:

JOSH McCOWN

Wow moment: There weren't any great plays, but it was a solid day. In fact, he was 5-for-5 in his limited action. At the end of practice, he was the quarterback in a walk-through of a two-minute drill, perhaps an indication he'll be in the game at the end of the first half.

Whoa moment: With Hackenberg and Petty sharing most of the action, McCown had a brief soft-toss with tight end Jordan Leggett off to the side. On Tuesday, he decided to run gassers on his own -- his way of staying active.

CHRISTIAN HACKENBERG

Wow moment: Every so often, he provides a glimpse of promise -- and it happened on a deep fade route to rookie wide receiver Chad Hansen. Hackenberg showed great touch on his high-arching pass, dropping it in the bucket, as they say. All told, he was 14-for-17, but keep it mind those numbers were compiled against the scout-team defense. Ditto, McCown and Petty.

Whoa moment: Not on this day.

BRYCE PETTY

Wow moment: His encouraging outing in Detroit has resulted in an increased number of reps. Petty was sharp, completing 9 of 10 passes. "Bryce has been picking it up pretty good and getting more comfortable in it," Bowles said. "He's been throwing the ball downfield more. I do see that." His best throw was a frozen rope to Robby Anderson, who made a juggling catch.

Whoa moment: It was a clean day in terms of turnovers, as it was for all three quarterbacks.
 
M

Mainejet

Guest
My hope is they allow Petty to start? Toilet already knows that McCown can be a starter. He probably will be when all is said and done. Bryce Petty showed some promise against the Lions and I agree that he should be getting more reps. So the Giants game should be all about Hack and Petty. Let Petty start and let him play well into the 3rd quarter. Then let Hack do mop up duty in the 4th quarter with the scrubs. Hack has not earned the opportunity to play with the ones and yet he's gotten plenty of opportunity. Overall, Petty has been the better QB and it's time to try and develop his talents. Let him hang himself if need be? Either way we need to make a decision regarding him.
 

soj

retired Veteran
Jet Fanatics
Agree... I'd like to see how he plays with the 1st... if he can play well and score TDs then start him... I rather take my lumps with him the Mac.
 

jetgreen13

founding JFU member..
Jet Fanatics
i"'m with you guys.. i would have liked to have seen petty have gotten a legitimate shot at the starting gig..

he hasn't/won't though.. my thoughts anyway..
 
Top