NFL could change defensive PI to 15-yard penalty

gmf1369

Jack of All Trades
Big Fish
The Mod Squad
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
The NFL is reportedly looking at implementing a number of rule changes, some expected (clarifying the catch rule) and some not so.

One of the surprising proposals offered by the NFL Competition Committee is to change the penalty for defensive pass interference from a spot foul to a 15-yard penalty at most, NFL Network's Judy Battista reported Tuesday. This is more in line with how the game is refereed on the collegiate level.

Changing the pass interference penalty is on its face a defense-first measure. Offenses would have far less to gain by "chucking it up" to try and draw a penalty from a grabby defensive back downfield.

Defensive pass interference was called 266 times in 2017, per Pro Football Reference, or more than once per game for an average of 18.09 yards per game. It was the third-most frequent flag behind offensive holding and false start.

In addition, and perhaps as a counter-measure, the league is expected to increase "illegal contact" calls as an effort to limit the amount of hand-fighting.

Battista reported the committee is also looking at potentially eliminating the "going to the ground" portion of the catch rule in attempt to clarify, changing the targeting rule and emphasizing more ejections for fighting.

"We are going to figure it out," said Stephen Jones, Cowboys executive vice president and competition committee member, in regard to the catch rule. "I do think we'll make some improvements that our fans, and in general, people will appreciate when it's all said and done."

Outside the lines, the NFL is also expected to implement a Josh McDaniels Rule. Battista reported a new measure to allow teams to hire coaches, even while their teams are still active in the playoffs, could be adopted.

The catalyst for this rule came earlier this month. The Colts were expected to hire McDaniels, then and still New England's offensive coordinator, as their next head coach, but couldn't until after the Pats were eliminated from the postseason. After the Super Bowl, McDaniels backed out of their handshake agreement, causing Indianapolis to scramble to find a replacement.

The NFL Competition Committee is made up of two owners, club presidents, general managers and head coaches. The Committee must present proposed measures to the 32 owners to be accepted. A new rule or a revision must have the support of 75 percent of the owners.
 

beresford

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
NFL is planning a number of rules changes, what a surprise. The Rules Committee is a sausage machine, to justify its existence sausages must be made whether they are required or not. Oh for the good old days when they just left the game alone.
 

McJet

Repeat Offender Pro Bowler
Jet Fanatics
That was a staple play in the Patriots playbook, third and long, chuck it up deep. For them it ws 50/50 that a flag would get thrown, now not only is it a 1st down but they are already in scoring range.
Thats what happened to the Jaguars in the playoffs against the Pats.First half winding down, the Patriots couldn't move the ball for sh!t. Out came the yellow Belicheck tissues, all the way down the field till they scored.
I'm sure Belicheck will put up a fight and it wont go through.
 

TonyFtLaud

I requested to be BANNED
Jet Fanatics
They should leave it as a spot foul. The league has done everything to make it a passing league and making it a 15 yard penalty will hurt the passing game.
DBs will be tackling WRs instead of giving up the deep pass. If passed, it will be reversed next season.
 

Jet Fan RI

Pro Bowl 1st Team
Jet Fanatics
They should leave it as a spot foul. The league has done everything to make it a passing league and making it a 15 yard penalty will hurt the passing game.
DBs will be tackling WRs instead of giving up the deep pass. If passed, it will be reversed next season.

I don't follow the college game. But do DB's tackle receivers on deep passes a lot?
 

Jet Fan RI

Pro Bowl 1st Team
Jet Fanatics
It's not uncommon and you can count on the announcers commenting it was a smart play, prevent the big gain, TD.

Well of course if a DB is beaten, he'll often tackle a receiver in the NFL as well in order to prevent a touchdown. The difference is how big the penalty would be. Not sure how I feel about changing to a 15 yarder.
 

LIJETFAN

G ~ Mod
Jet Fanatics
I'm all for it! I would also like to see the illegal contact rule changed to a penalty that does not give an automatic first down. You take away half of the Patriots offense by changing these two rules.
 

TonyFtLaud

I requested to be BANNED
Jet Fanatics
I'm all for it! I would also like to see the illegal contact rule changed to a penalty that does not give an automatic first down. You take away half of the Patriots offense by changing these two rules.

Same could be said for Pittsburgh, Green Bay, Houston, Miami, Indy. All who average way more PI calls in their favor, over the past 10 years than NE.
On the bright side, Skrine would have been a pro bowl DB last season if this rule was in place....:global (31):
 

isired

Pro Bowl Alternate
Jet Fanatics
I think it should depend on field location. PI in the end zone puts the ball in the 1. PI in the red zone is a spot foul. 15 yards everywhere else
 

Elias

The Invisible Man
Big Fish
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
This helps the defense a lot in my opinion, like JetfanRI said, once beat they’d tackle the player to not let up a score.

I can see this rule backfiring. I’m all for not making illegal contact an automatic first down.
 
Top