Zach Wilson topped the NFL in the wrong kind of metric

jets82

Curious George
Jet Fanatics
New York Jets quarterback Zach Wilson finished his rookie season with lackluster numbers in the box score. He completed 213 of 383 passes (55.6%) for 2,334 yards, nine touchdowns, and 11 interceptions, earning a 69.7 passer rating that ranked last among qualifiers.

The lowliness of those numbers is not entirely his fault, though.

Wilson led all qualified NFL quarterbacks in a category that no team should want their young quarterback to lead the league in: drop rate.

According to Pro Football Focus, Wilson had 12.7% of his catchable passes dropped, which was the highest rate in the NFL among 35 qualified quarterbacks.

Not only did Wilson rank No. 1 in the category, but he was in his own stratosphere:

  1. Zach Wilson, 12.7%
  2. Jacoby Brissett, 9.6%
  3. Sam Darnold, 9.3%
  4. Trevor Lawrence, 9.3%
  5. Baker Mayfield, 9.0%
  6. Matthew Stafford, 8.0%
  7. Justin Herbert, 7.9%
  8. Ben Roethlisberger, 7.8%
  9. Justin Fields, 7.6%
  10. Daniel Jones, 7.6%
Now, as I have written about before, it’s important to note that a high drop rate can be an indicator of poor accuracy on the quarterback’s part. Many “drops” come on imperfect throws, so, naturally, inaccurate quarterbacks will create more opportunities for their receivers to drop passes.

This hypothesis is supported by the talent level of the quarterbacks at the top of the drop leaderboard. Look at Wilson’s company in the top five: Jacoby Brissett, Sam Darnold, Trevor Lawrence, and Baker Mayfield. All four quarterbacks were poor this year.

In 2020, the top five quarterbacks in drop rate were Carson Wentz, Daniel Jones, Drew Lock, Andy Dalton, and Tua Tagovailoa. All five had rough seasons.

Wilson can certainly own a piece of his drop rate. His accuracy was erratic at times, especially early in the year, and some of the “drops” his receivers got tagged with could have been thrown much better.

However, the fact that Wilson’s drop rate was that much higher than the rest of the NFL is a clear indictment of his pass-catchers’ enormous struggles.

Just look at the separation between Wilson’s drop rate and second-ranked Brissett’s drop rate. The 3.1% difference between Wilson (12.7%) and Brissett (9.6%) is equal to the difference between Brissett and 22nd-ranked Josh Allen (6.5%) out of 35 qualifiers.

That is completely absurd. While a quarterback has some control over his drop rate, an astronomically high number like Wilson’s can only occur as a result of terrible play from the pass-catchers.

There are some areas in which the Jets did a decent job of supporting Wilson. Their pass protection and run game became respectable later in the year when the offensive line was healthy, and offensive coordinator Mike LaFleur did a nice job of manufacturing offense.

Securing easy catches was not one of those areas. New York’s pass-catchers botched way too many good throws from Wilson.

Not only did Wilson have to fight through a frequency of drops that no other quarterback came close to, but a lot of his drops came on fantastic throws that should have yielded big-time yardage and momentum.




Corey Davis had a rough season in this department, dropping six passes. His 15.0% drop rate ranked fourth-worst out of 117 qualified wide receivers. That is a major outlier for Davis. Over his four seasons, Davis never had a drop rate higher than 5.8% or a drop total higher than four. The Jets need him to get back to that level.

Top weapons Elijah Moore (2 drops, 4.4% rate) and Braxton Berrios (1 drop, 2.1% rate) secured the ball effectively, but the wideouts at the very bottom of New York’s depth chart struggled mightily. Denzel Mims (2 drops), Jeff Smith (2), and Tarik Black (1) combined for five drops against only 17 receptions (22.7% rate).

The Jets need their running backs to display much softer hands, too. Ty Johnson led all running backs with nine drops and a 20.9% drop rate. Michael Carter tied for sixth in drops with five while his 12.2% drop rate ranked seventh-worst out of 49 qualified running backs.

The same goes for the tight end position. Tyler Kroft and Ryan Griffin caught very few passes, yet Kroft tied for eighth among tight ends with four drops and Griffin tied for 16th with three. Kroft’s 20.0% drop rate was the worst among 52 qualified tight ends while Griffin’s 10.0% rate was seventh-worst.

All of this makes one thing clear: when evaluating potential additions to improve the offensive skill positions this offseason, Joe Douglas and the Jets need to have “strong hands” as the No. 1 must-have skill on their checklist.

I don’t know if anyone posted this article or started a thread like this but if not, this article shows Zach Wilson dropped passes rate and how much higher it is than any other QB and why!
 

Tinstar

Mr. Know it All
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
This article makes one small omission. Just maybe, and I’m not saying it’s true or not, but just maybe the Rook doesn’t throw a catchable ball .
 

TebowCan'tThrow

Supersize!
The Mod Squad
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
This article makes one small omission. Just maybe, and I’m not saying it’s true or not, but just maybe the Rook doesn’t throw a catchable ball .

He definitely had some horrible drops that weren't his fault, but some definitely were. The Jets need a true #1 so we can stop making excuses. Either he makes the WR's around him better or he doesn't. Hope we find out next season.
 

TebowCan'tThrow

Supersize!
The Mod Squad
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
I agree.

Some balls could've been placed better and some balls had no business of being dropped.

And I agree x2.

Zach Wilson needs an Adams type of true #1 veteran WR in their prime.

Just look at what S. Diggs has done for Josh Allen and his progression. It's nuts.

I'm just hopeful that all of these (multiple) reports that I'm reading of Jets being a top 1-3 potential landing spot for Davante Adams are both accurate and true.

Because I couldn't imagine our draft flexibility heading into round 1 with a WR unit featuring the likes of Davante Adams, Corey Davis and Elijah Moore (and hopefully Braxton Berrios) with still untapped potential in Denzel Mims.

I don't think JD would sign Adams. It would be a game changer for this offense though.
 

gmf1369

Jack of All Trades
Big Fish
The Mod Squad
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
If Davante Adams does indeed hit the open market? I'm one who would become absolutely shocked if Joe Douglas didn't go after him guns blazing (with Zazh Wilson in his ear telling him to please please plz do so)
he isn't looking to sign big time contracts
he is looking for players coming off their rookie deals that compliment the roster
he is looking to draft players
he is looking if the proper trade deal is there for an expiring contract when the roster is at a competitive instance
but until then lets enjoy the ride and not play the what if game
especially since it becomes a problem
 

Innocenti

Ospedale degli Innocenti
Jet Fanatics
This article makes one small omission. Just maybe, and I’m not saying it’s true or not, but just maybe the Rook doesn’t throw a catchable ball .
I Agree and I've said basically the same thing several times during the season. His timing has been off on the short passes causing him to overthrow or have bad placement. On deeper throws, receivers have more time to adjust so it's not as much of an issue.
 

jets82

Curious George
Jet Fanatics
Zach definitely has to settle down and go with the flow of the game. Especially with those short passes, he appears to not have the right grasp in those situations. The kid has all the talent in the world. He just has to put it all together.

Oh yeah, a little thing like some help from his skilled players may be an BIG ISSUE also. All he truly had consistently all year was E. Moore, M. Carter and B. Berrios and even they had their injury issues at times. C. Davis and Crowder always seemed to be hurt, Mims was a no show or couldn’t get on the field. Yeboah they wouldn’t give a chance to. K. Cole wasn’t as consistent as needed and every other RB, WR or TE on the team just isn’t even worth mentioning! They got some serious work to do for next year.
 

Old#15

Old Wise Tale
Jet Fanatics
A question: How much can a QB work out with teammates during the offseason? Is it theoretically an unlimited window? If I were him, I'd do it as much as possible and guys like Mims ought to be camping out on his doorstep to get as much work in as possible.
 

skop

The Green Knight
Jet Fanatics
A question: How much can a QB work out with teammates during the offseason? Is it theoretically an unlimited window? If I were him, I'd do it as much as possible and guys like Mims ought to be camping out on his doorstep to get as much work in as possible.

Correct...as long as coaches are not involved, players can hold their own quasi-mini camps. and they should.
 

skop

The Green Knight
Jet Fanatics
A lot of the drop pass rate falls in Zach's lap...

(1.) when you are erratic in getting the ball out in time, and to the correct spot, incompletions pile up.
(2.) Receivers have to be mentally tough to then run a correct route and continue to expect the next throw to them to be on time in the right spot.
(3.) so when Zach does make a throw that should be caught, it might be something unexpected.

Having said that, his receivers needed to help him out too. just as they might have been thrown off by his erratic play, they have to make a few "bail out the rookie" plays to settle him down so he didn't feel like he had to start placing the ball perfectly for him.

The thing that gives me optimism for Zach is that he kept trying to get better within the offense, and kept trying to make better throws regardless of the outcomes...in short, he kept trying to do his job better and forced the receivers to do their jobs.
 

Seaver41

Pro Bowl 1st Team
Jet Fanatics
tale of two seasons........his accuracy was much better late - short stuff too.....but the drops seemed to get worse at wrong time. Let's also remember his increased ball security awareness led to him being smart and throwing more balls away. He needs to further refine his mechanics but that is standard stuff teams look at.

Big point that has to be made is just how often does anyone remember seeing a Jet WR make a GREAT catch? To have those lofty stats a QB must have receivers that ball out and make the difficult catches to extend drives and also not put QB in bad down/distance on next play - which in turn makes the next throw more difficult- and in turn...well you get the point. Pass stats will go up with better hands, separation, and line protection...not to mention what a sustained running attack does to benefit QBs.
 

skop

The Green Knight
Jet Fanatics
Big point that has to be made is just how often does anyone remember seeing a Jet WR make a GREAT catch?

this is a question i asked many times this year...the only one that really made a highlight reel was the Davis TD vs. TENN, but that wasn't even a great catch as much as it was a derivative of great orchestration and a great pass.

the tweet in the original post to this thread illustrating receiver drops on balls in their hands were drive killers.
 
Top