Differences in all-pro caliber/HOF QBs and their organizations

jets82

Curious George
Jet Fanatics
This is all just my opinion obviously but if you look at QBs and their organizations over the past 30 years or so, as compared to what we have been dealing with you can see a major difference. Not all the all-pro caliber and HOF (elected or soon to be) QBs were born and bread to be that, they were just drafted to the right organizations at the right time. For example:

- Tom Brady and Joe Montana are now known as two of the greatest QBs to ever touch a football. They were drafted to teams that groomed them correctly, build around them the right way and they won 5-plus SBs with their teams. Both are or will be first ballot HOFers and are the Mount Rushmore of QBs so far.

- Russell Wilson and Big Ben were drafted to winning organizations and all they had to do was stay out the way and do their part for the first 2-3 years and the organizations won. After that, both QBs were ready to take over the team and be the true franchise QBs that they could count on. Both will become become first ballot HOFers when they retire.

- Troy Aikman and Peyton Manning were QBs that were drafted to organizations that were terrible at the time. Both QBs showed them that they had the goods, had heart and could lead the team if they build around them correctly. The teams did and they became SB winners and first ballot HOFers.

- Brett Farve and Aaron Rodgers both played for a Green Bay team that were struggling at the time but the caliber of QBs that they are/were, they dragged the teams along to some success. The teams build around them correctly and they won SBs and both QBs are or will be first ballot HOFers.

- Dan Marino and Jim Kelly both went to teams that were good at the time but these QBs took them to a whole nothing level. No the teams didn't win any SBs but these QBs lead both teams to success for many years and both QBs are first ballot HOFers.

- Cam Newton, Lamar Jackson, Patrick Mahomes and Deshawn Watson are all QBs that appear to be damn near Supermen. Whether drafted by the right organization or not, we all can see that they have the goods. Now Watson is struggling a little bit without his top WR but he will figure it out and the Texans will be ok with him. All QBs IMO are destined for first ballot HOF.

- I say or post all of this to bring up our situation. When was the last time you can think of, after Joe Namath retired that the Jets have drafted a QB that no matter what the situation was, he was still going to make something happen and we could still win with this guy?

NEVER!!!

- Ok, so when was the last time, since Joe Namath retired that you can think that the Jets have drafted a QB that they build the team around him correctly and he helped us win and he became a franchise winning QB?

NO ONE, I SORTA KINDA WANT TO SAY KEN OBRIEN BUT THEN AGAIN, HE WAS NOT A TRUE FRANCHISE QB. HE WAS DECENT AT BEST.

- Ok, so now can you name a QB or QBs that the Jets have drafted, after Namath retired that the team was ready to win from game one and all he had to do was not mess it up, do his part and they would win and he also grow into our franchise winning QB?

Mark Sanchez, was drafted into a great situation with Rex Ryan and that team was ready to win from year one. Problem is Mark couldn't really just do his part and stay out the freaking way and let the team lead him to a SB victory or two. Sanchez also wasn't ready to take over and lead them after they ruined everything and tore the team apart in his third year. Sanchez was overwhelmed and couldn't handle the franchise QB duties and he washed out.

Now here we are with Darnold, drafted to a horrible team under horrible conditions but he can't seem to make it happen like a Cam Newton or Peyton Manning did with their teams. He will most likely be gone next year and we will be starting all over again with whomever. This Jets team has to change its thinking and the way they do things or we keep running on the hamster wheel with every QB they draft. Unless they luck up and draft a Superman like P. Manning or Cam Newton who regardless of the situation, we will be contender and he will be our franchise QB!
 
Last edited:

NewMFS62

Weeb's Mentor
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
I think the situation is more like Archie Manning, who was highly touted and had all the skills, but got drafted my a team that had him running for his life for most of his career.
Later
 

gmf1369

Jack of All Trades
Big Fish
The Mod Squad
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
I will say my piece and you can take it how you want but for us we finally got that guy in Sam Darnold the rub of it is that we don't yet have that coach to take his game to the next level...

He has the "It" factor, he has shown not consistently but on occasion that he can make all the plays...

We never surrounded him with enough talent, that is the rub... Robby Anderson was the up and comer but who was that number two guy?

Yes we drafted Herndon to be his sure handed tight end but this is the first year that Herndon has been healthy enough to play and is literally dropping the ball...

A solid run game would allow Sam to develop himself but there is the rub again our coordinator/head coach can not get the run game going outside of touting the rock to 37 year Gore...

just read that Gase this past week finally upped the tempo at practice for the offense, that doesn't help if they don't have Sam oh wait this week is Flacco week... Only way for Sam can take that next level is he understands all scenarios... Reads then reacts not second guesses himself... Gase has him overthinking his decision making... That is why Darnold is throwing the ball into bad situations... Only way to get him moving forward is the next head coach is just that the head coach who hires his offensive coordinator and quarterback coach report to the head coach and the three jobs are not one guy...

Repetitiveness, becomes second nature and that makes a quarterback like Sam lethal... Darnold has the ability of making something from nothing when it all breaks down but if he doesn't have to decide on the go and just react to what he sees then he will take players like Berrios, Jeff Smith, Mims, and Crowder then make them into legit receiver's group in the league... All these guys showed they can ball but if the quarterback is second guessing the defensive sets he is facing and then forces the ball into the receiver that is not only double covered but has less than a 10% chance do anything with the ball if he catches it...

Have to wonder if moving forward they give him that chance to grow?
 

Shea Jet

Day 3 Prospect
Jet Fanatics
This is all just my opinion obviously but if you look at QBs and their organizations over the past 30 years or so, as compared to what we have been dealing with you can see a major difference. Not all the all-pro caliber and HOF (elected or soon to be) QBs were born and bread to be that, they were just drafted to the right organizations at the right time. For example:

- Tom Brady and Joe Montana are now known as two of the greatest QBs to ever touch a football. They were drafted to teams that groomed them correctly, build around them the right way and they won 5-plus SBs with their teams. Both are or will be first ballot HOFers and are the Mount Rushmore of QBs so far.

- Russell Wilson and Big Ben were drafted to winning organizations and all they had to do was stay out the way and do their part for the first 2-3 years and the organizations won. After that, both QBs were ready to take over the team and be the true franchise QBs that they could count on. Both will become become first ballot HOFers when they retire.

- Troy Aikman and Peyton Manning were QBs that were drafted to organizations that were terrible at the time. Both QBs showed them that they had the goods, had heart and could lead the team if they build around them correctly. The teams did and they became SB winners and first ballot HOFers.

- Brett Farve and Aaron Rodgers both played for a Green Bay team that were struggling at the time but the caliber of QBs that they are/were, they dragged the teams along to some success. The teams build around them correctly and they won SBs and both QBs are or will be first ballot HOFers.

- Dan Marino and Jim Kelly both went to teams that were good at the time but these QBs took them to a whole nothing level. No the teams didn't win any SBs but these QBs lead both teams to success for many years and both QBs are first ballot HOFers.

- Cam Newton, Lamar Jackson, Patrick Mahomes and Deshawn Watson are all QBs that appear to be damn near Supermen. Whether drafted by the right organization or not, we all can see that they have the goods. Now Watson is struggling a little bit without his top WR but he will figure it out and the Texans will be ok with him. All QBs IMO are destined for first ballot HOF.

- I say or post all of this to bring up our situation. When was the last time you can think of, after Joe Namath retired that the Jets have drafted a QB that no matter what the situation was, he was still going to make something happen and we could still win with this guy?

NEVER!!!

- Ok, so when was the last time, since Joe Namath retired that you can think that the Jets have drafted a QB that they build the team around him correctly and he helped us win and he became a franchise winning QB?

NO ONE, I SORTA KINDA WANT TO SAY KEN OBRIEN BUT THEN AGAIN, HE WAS NOT A TRUE FRANCHISE QB. HE WAS DECENT AT BEST.

- Ok, so now can you name a QB or QBs that the Jets have drafted, after Namath retired that the team was ready to win from game one and all he had to do was not mess it up, do his part and they would win and he also grow into our franchise winning QB?

Mark Sanchez, was drafted into a great situation with Rex Ryan and that team was ready to win from year one. Problem is Mark couldn't really just do his part and stay out the freaking way and let the team lead him to a SB victory or two. Sanchez also wasn't ready to take over and lead them after they ruined everything and tore the team apart in his third year. Sanchez was overwhelmed and couldn't handle the franchise QB duties and he washed out.

Now here we are with Darnold, drafted to a horrible team under horrible conditions but he can't seem to make it happen like a Cam Newton or Peyton Manning did with their teams. He will most likely be gone next year and we will be starting all over again with whomever. This Jets team has to change its thinking and the way they do things or we keep running on the hamster wheel with every QB they draft. Unless they luck up and draft a Superman like P. Manning or Cam Newton who regardless of the situation, we will be contender and he will be our franchise QB!

Your first 5 Quarterback Paragraphs are spot on.
Your last one on the recent Quarterbacks are WAY off. ONLY Mahomes can be looked at RIGHT NOW as First Ballot HOF material. Calling Jackson and Watson First Ballot HOFers now is totally irresponsible and flat out INCORRECT Even Cam is not a FIRST Ballot HOFer, maybe 2nd or 3rd Ballot.
 

jets82

Curious George
Jet Fanatics
Your first 5 Quarterback Paragraphs are spot on.
Your last one on the recent Quarterbacks are WAY off. ONLY Mahomes can be looked at RIGHT NOW as First Ballot HOF material. Calling Jackson and Watson First Ballot HOFers now is totally irresponsible and flat out INCORRECT Even Cam is not a FIRST Ballot HOFer, maybe 2nd or 3rd Ballot.
I can respect the rebuttal and appreciate it but I think misunderstood the post. As four the four youngsters, they all may not be 1st ballot guys right now but you can see it in them that they will be. Let’s look at it:

- Mahomes is Mahomes and the really is nothing more to be said about that.
- Jackson is with a organization that since they became the Ravens has always done it the right way. So as long as Ozzie Newsone and that HC stays there, they will keep building correctly around Jackson and he will only get better and better and he will be a 1st ballot guy.
- Watson has been a beast since day one on a Texans team that was playoff ready at all. He still made it happen and still does till this day. He will continue to flourish, especially under better coaching and management and how can you not say that this guy won’t be a 1st ballot HOFer.
- Cam was a beast since day one on a team that also wasn’t so hot. They build with him and he’s put up overall HOF numbers damn near every year he was there. You could see the true talent and IT factor in him and that hasn’t changed. Now he’s with NE and sky’s the limit. We see what he’s done so far, so how can you argue that he won’t be a 1st ballot guy when his time is done.
 

jets82

Curious George
Jet Fanatics
I will say my piece and you can take it how you want but for us we finally got that guy in Sam Darnold the rub of it is that we don't yet have that coach to take his game to the next level...

He has the "It" factor, he has shown not consistently but on occasion that he can make all the plays...

We never surrounded him with enough talent, that is the rub... Robby Anderson was the up and comer but who was that number two guy?

Yes we drafted Herndon to be his sure handed tight end but this is the first year that Herndon has been healthy enough to play and is literally dropping the ball...

A solid run game would allow Sam to develop himself but there is the rub again our coordinator/head coach can not get the run game going outside of touting the rock to 37 year Gore...

just read that Gase this past week finally upped the tempo at practice for the offense, that doesn't help if they don't have Sam oh wait this week is Flacco week... Only way for Sam can take that next level is he understands all scenarios... Reads then reacts not second guesses himself... Gase has him overthinking his decision making... That is why Darnold is throwing the ball into bad situations... Only way to get him moving forward is the next head coach is just that the head coach who hires his offensive coordinator and quarterback coach report to the head coach and the three jobs are not one guy...

Repetitiveness, becomes second nature and that makes a quarterback like Sam lethal... Darnold has the ability of making something from nothing when it all breaks down but if he doesn't have to decide on the go and just react to what he sees then he will take players like Berrios, Jeff Smith, Mims, and Crowder then make them into legit receiver's group in the league... All these guys showed they can ball but if the quarterback is second guessing the defensive sets he is facing and then forces the ball into the receiver that is not only double covered but has less than a 10% chance do anything with the ball if he catches it...

Have to wonder if moving forward they give him that chance to grow?
Agreed 1,000 percent on all points!
 

jets82

Curious George
Jet Fanatics
I think the situation is more like Archie Manning, who was highly touted and had all the skills, but got drafted my a team that had him running for his life for most of his career.
Later
This is probably spot on. I never actually watched a game of Archie Manning but I’ve seen the highlights and heard about his talent. This is exactly what Sam is dealing with. True amazing talent but pretty much on the damn field by himself.
 
Last edited:

Shea Jet

Day 3 Prospect
Jet Fanatics
I can respect the rebuttal and appreciate it but I think misunderstood the post. As four the four youngsters, they all may not be 1st ballot guys right now but you can see it in them that they will be. Let’s look at it:

- Mahomes is Mahomes and the really is nothing more to be said about that.
- Jackson is with a organization that since they became the Ravens has always done it the right way. So as long as Ozzie Newsone and that HC stays there, they will keep building correctly around Jackson and he will only get better and better and he will be a 1st ballot guy.
- Watson has been a beast since day one on a Texans team that was playoff ready at all. He still made it happen and still does till this day. He will continue to flourish, especially under better coaching and management and how can you not say that this guy won’t be a 1st ballot HOFer.
- Cam was a beast since day one on a team that also wasn’t so hot. They build with him and he’s put up overall HOF numbers damn near every year he was there. You could see the true talent and IT factor in him and that hasn’t changed. Now he’s with NE and sky’s the limit. We see what he’s done so far, so how can you argue that he won’t be a 1st ballot guy when his time is done.

Cam isnt a "First Ballot" because he a. Never won a Super Bowl (so far) and b.doesnt have a ton of seasons with prolific passing stats. c. Not a prolific Regular Season winner with many Playoff wins to his credit. ELI MANNING may not get in on 1st ballot and he's got 2 Rings!!! I could live with Cam being HOF material and eventually getting in but let's save the 1st ballots for the "slam dunk" guys. Active QB's in this category include Brady,,Brees, Rodgers,,Wilson and probably Big Ben.

I hear what you're saying on Lamar and Deshaun, but let's wait til Lamar DOESNT lose a Home Playoff Game as a Touchdown favorite (0-2 in Playoffs) and Deshaun is already trending downward.

But like I said, your first 5 paragraphs were spot on, and all in all a great post!
 

jets82

Curious George
Jet Fanatics
Cam isnt a "First Ballot" because he a. Never won a Super Bowl (so far) and b.doesnt have a ton of seasons with prolific passing stats. c. Not a prolific Regular Season winner with many Playoff wins to his credit. ELI MANNING may not get in on 1st ballot and he's got 2 Rings!!! I could live with Cam being HOF material and eventually getting in but let's save the 1st ballots for the "slam dunk" guys. Active QB's in this category include Brady,,Brees, Rodgers,,Wilson and probably Big Ben.

I hear what you're saying on Lamar and Deshaun, but let's wait til Lamar DOESNT lose a Home Playoff Game as a Touchdown favorite (0-2 in Playoffs) and Deshaun is already trending downward.

But like I said, your first 5 paragraphs were spot on, and all in all a great post!
I say this also, the way the Bills are building around Josh Allen and how he's developing, he might be good for it also.
 

butterscotch

Jets/Cards
Jets Global
This is probably spot on. I never actually watched a game of Archie Manning but I’ve seen the highlights and heard about his talent. This is exactly what Sam is dealing with. True amazing talent but pretty much on the damn field by himself.
I did see him & a bad Giants team & jets team could beat that team without trying.
 

butterscotch

Jets/Cards
Jets Global
We still don;t know if the D man is a winner or loser. time will tell. He is a Boring person but that may be good,
 
Top