The Back-up Quarterback battle: Bryce Petty vs Geno Smith

[ReallyBigfan]

Geno Smith===Ryan Leaf :Banane56:

Time to move on

Either you never saw Ryan Leaf play or you don't understand the first thing about football. On his worst day Geno was still way better than Ryan Leaf ever was.

 

[jetgreen13]

That's just plain silly, lounap. You do understand that having a great #1 WR like Marshall takes defensive attention away from Decker and makes it easier for him to put up numbers, right? And again, Decker was hobbled by a hamstring injury for practically the entire 2014 season, or he would have had even better numbers with Geno!

if petty plays well tomorrow night my guess is he takes the 2nd spot on the depth chart from smith..

but there's competition for the job, so what the hell do i know?? aside from understanding how to read between the lines.....

 

[ReallyBigfan]

Lol, why do I have to be trying to prove something? I am merely expressing my opinion, which, since it disagrees with yours, prompts you to be insulting and obnoxious. That's fine, I don't know you from a hole in the wall and could care less what you think or say, notwithstanding the fact that on the whole, I prefer civil, intelligent discourse to your brand of arrogant, irrational pap. And there is the added benefit of the entertainment value of you twisting every development to fit your know-it-all opinions.

As Charlie Casserly said, the Jets HAVE to give Petty as many reps as they can to be sure that it is worth their while to keep four QBs - not because he is competing with Geno at this stage. Is it possible that Petty shines through so brightly that the Jets reconsider? Sure, that is possible although improbable, given his complete lack of any NFL game experience whatsoever. And btw, I am pretty sure that Geno's "they make it up" tweet was referring to this - the media acting as though the CS giving extra reps to Petty was an indication that he was competing with Geno, despite Bowles stating clearly that that was not the case, and not understanding that the Jets simply need to see as much of Petty as they can before making the key roster decisions.

Btw, Geno had one season with Decker, 2014, during which Decker battled a hamstring problem almost the entire season. Despite that, and despite Decker being Geno's only real weapon so that opposing teams knew they just had to focus on taking Decker away... Despite all that, Decker had only SIX fewer catches and 65 fewer receiving yards in 2014 than he had in the 2015 season! So you reveal what an oblivious farce you are when you make demonstrably false claims like saying that Geno created zero chemistry with Decker, when a hobbled Decker in 2014 had essentially as good a year with Geno as a healthy Decker had in 2015 with Fitz.[/QUOTE]

Classic Geno apologist post....... All Geno had to do was show something, anything to give an indication that he was deserving of more time. He never showed a thing. On top of all of that, he proved he was a JERK. So all in all, he proved nothing on the football field, but he did prove to the fan base that he was a jerk.

Nice way to ignore the point. YOU claimed that Geno never established any chemistry with Decker in 2014 and I proved with straightforward statistics that you were absolutely, demonstrably, wrong. That was the only point of that paragraph, so your typical anti-Geno rant in response which completely ignores the whole Geno-Decker issue, is a solid example of the irrational pap to which I referred, as is your "classic Geno apologist post" remark. I wasn't being an apologist, I was disproving your claim that Geno established no chemistry with Decker. Instead of showing at least a little bit of class and acknowledging that Geno-Decker had more success in 2014 than you realized, you just reverted to off-topic Geno bashing, which is what you always do.

 

[hatnlvr]

Either you never saw Ryan Leaf play or you don't understand the first thing about football. On his worst day Geno was still way better than Ryan Leaf ever was.

You should really learn how to take joking and sarcasm and get out of your feelings.

 

[Bigmoe]

For the life of me I don't get how anyone defends Geno
I've sat in my seats and have seen every starting Qb for the Jets since 71' and I'd like anybody to tell me who they disliked more than Geno
He not only sucks but he's a Dick
Please tell me


2015- Fitz

2014- Geno Smith

2013 — Geno Smith (16)

2012 — Mark Sanchez (15), Greg McElroy (1)

2011 — Mark Sanchez (16)

2010 — Mark Sanchez (16)

2009 — Mark Sanchez (15), Kellen Clemens (1)

2008 — Brett Favre (16)

2007 — Chad Pennington (8), Kellen Clemens (8)

2006 — Chad Pennington (16)

2005 — Brooks Bollinger (9), Vinny Testaverde (4), Chad Pennington (3)

2004 — Chad Pennington (13), Quincy Carter (3)

2003 — Chad Pennington (9), Vinny Testaverde (7)

2002 — Chad Pennington (12), Vinny Testaverde (4)

2001 — Vinny Testaverde (16)

2000 — Vinny Testaverde (16)

1999 — Ray Lucas (9), Rick Mirer (6), Vinny Testaverde (1)

1998 — Vinny Testaverde (13), Glenn Foley (3)

1997 — Neil O'Donnell (14), Glenn Foley (2)

1996 — Frank Reich (7), Neil O'Donnell (6), Glenn Foley (3)

1995 — Boomer Esiason (12), Bubby Brister (4)

1994 — Boomer Esiason (14), Jack Trudeau (2)

1993 — Boomer Esiason (16)

1992 — Browning Nagle (13), Ken O'Brien (3)

1991 — Ken O'Brien (16)

1990 — Ken O'Brien (16)

1989 — Ken O'Brien (12), Tony Eason (2), Pat Ryan (1), Kyle Mackey (1)

1988 — Ken O'Brien (12), Pat Ryan (4)

1987 — Ken O'Brien (12), David Norrie (2), Pat Ryan (1)

1986 — Ken O'Brien (14), Pat Ryan (2)

1985 — Ken O'Brien (16)

1984 — Pat Ryan (11), Ken O'Brien (5)

1983 — Richard Todd (16)

1982 — Richard Todd (9)

1981 — Richard Todd (16)

1980 — Richard Todd (16)

1979 — Richard Todd (15), Matt Robinson (1)

1978 — Matt Robinson (11), Richard Todd (5)

1977 — Richard Todd (11), Matt Robinson (1), Marty Domres (2)

1976-Joe Namath (8) / Richard Todd (6)
1975- Joe Namath (13) / J.J. Jones (1)
1974 - Joe Namath (14)
1973 -Al Woodall (6) / Joe Namath (5) / Bill Demory (3)
1972- Joe Namath (13) / Bob Davis (1)
1971 -Bob Davis (7) / Al Woodall (4) / Joe Namath (3)

___

 

[BlindsideD'Brick]

Please point out to me where it is I am being insulting and obnoxious anywhere in my post?

Just this post, or your entire history posting on this board?

 

[Mainejet]

if petty plays well tomorrow night my guess is he takes the 2nd spot on the depth chart from smith..

but there's competition for the job, so what the hell do i know?? aside from understanding how to read between the lines.....

I'm with you buddy....:global (41):

 

[Mainejet]

Just this post, or your entire history posting on this board?

Now Geno and Blindside can go and sulk in the corner together...........

 

[McJet]

For the life of me I don't get how anyone defends Geno
I've sat in my seats and have seen every starting Qb for the Jets since 71' and I'd like anybody to tell me who they disliked more than Geno
He not only sucks but he's a Dick
Please tell me


2015- Fitz

2014- Geno Smith

2013 — Geno Smith (16)

2012 — Mark Sanchez (15), Greg McElroy (1)

2011 — Mark Sanchez (16)

2010 — Mark Sanchez (16)

2009 — Mark Sanchez (15), Kellen Clemens (1)

2008 — Brett Favre (16)

2007 — Chad Pennington (8), Kellen Clemens (8)

2006 — Chad Pennington (16)

2005 — Brooks Bollinger (9), Vinny Testaverde (4), Chad Pennington (3)

2004 — Chad Pennington (13), Quincy Carter (3)

2003 — Chad Pennington (9), Vinny Testaverde (7)

2002 — Chad Pennington (12), Vinny Testaverde (4)

2001 — Vinny Testaverde (16)

2000 — Vinny Testaverde (16)

1999 — Ray Lucas (9), Rick Mirer (6), Vinny Testaverde (1)

1998 — Vinny Testaverde (13), Glenn Foley (3)

1997 — Neil O'Donnell (14), Glenn Foley (2)

1996 — Frank Reich (7), Neil O'Donnell (6), Glenn Foley (3)

1995 — Boomer Esiason (12), Bubby Brister (4)

1994 — Boomer Esiason (14), Jack Trudeau (2)

1993 — Boomer Esiason (16)

1992 — Browning Nagle (13), Ken O'Brien (3)

1991 — Ken O'Brien (16)

1990 — Ken O'Brien (16)

1989 — Ken O'Brien (12), Tony Eason (2), Pat Ryan (1), Kyle Mackey (1)

1988 — Ken O'Brien (12), Pat Ryan (4)

1987 — Ken O'Brien (12), David Norrie (2), Pat Ryan (1)

1986 — Ken O'Brien (14), Pat Ryan (2)

1985 — Ken O'Brien (16)

1984 — Pat Ryan (11), Ken O'Brien (5)

1983 — Richard Todd (16)

1982 — Richard Todd (9)

1981 — Richard Todd (16)

1980 — Richard Todd (16)

1979 — Richard Todd (15), Matt Robinson (1)

1978 — Matt Robinson (11), Richard Todd (5)

1977 — Richard Todd (11), Matt Robinson (1), Marty Domres (2)

1976-Joe Namath (8) / Richard Todd (6)
1975- Joe Namath (13) / J.J. Jones (1)
1974 - Joe Namath (14)
1973 -Al Woodall (6) / Joe Namath (5) / Bill Demory (3)
1972- Joe Namath (13) / Bob Davis (1)
1971 -Bob Davis (7) / Al Woodall (4) / Joe Namath (3)

___

For me, Neil O'Donnell is right up there.

 

[Elias]

Now Geno and Blindside can go and sulk in the corner together...........

not cool MJ. Let's not make this more than a QB debate, pls

 

[SackExchange]

not cool MJ. Let's not make this more than a QB debate, pls

Thank you.

 

[TebowCan'tThrow]

They need to cut Geno so Petty can have his reps. If Fitz goes down I want see youth and not another throw from Geno. I'm watching Dak Prescott throwing 90% completion with 4 TD's and 1 rush TD in two weeks. I sure hope Petty is our QB next year. Of course Dallas has a much better OL and that really helps, but I want a short leash on Fitz and at most one year.

 

[Elias]

They need to cut Geno so Petty can have his reps. If Fitz goes down I want see youth and not another throw from Geno. I'm watching Dak Prescott throwing 90% completion with 4 TD's and 1 rush TD in two weeks. I sure hope Petty is our QB next year. Of course Dallas has a much better OL and that really helps, but I want a short leash on Fitz and at most one year.

Petty has looked good when he has warmed up and is in the flow of the game. At first he struggles but then he looks good. Not sure if it's because the third stringers are in or if it's because he's getting better as the game progresses.

 

[Elias]

We cannot cut Petty. If he continues to develop as he did from year 1 to year 2, then he may very well turn into starter material. I am crossing my fingers

 

[Green Jets & Ham]

We cannot cut Petty. If he continues to develop as he did from year 1 to year 2, then he may very well turn into starter material. I am crossing my fingers

I would love to see him get some time with the #1 offensive line, behind a line that can pass block.

He looks good despite being under siege, imagine how much better he might look if you give him some time in the pocket.

 

[TebowCan'tThrow]

We cannot cut Petty. If he continues to develop as he did from year 1 to year 2, then he may very well turn into starter material. I am crossing my fingers

But we can cut Geno!!

 

[TebowCan'tThrow]

I would love to see him get some time with the #1 offensive line, behind a line that can pass block.

He looks good despite being under siege, imagine how much better he might look if you give him some time in the pocket.

He might look like Dak Prescott. Of course Prescott is playing against a vanilla defense.

 

[Green Jets & Ham]

But we can cut Geno!!

Does this mean you will NOT be drafting Geno in our fantasy league? :global (21):

 

[TebowCan'tThrow]

Does this mean you will NOT be drafting Geno in our fantasy league? :global (21):

I won't be drafting any Jets QB.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Mainejet]

not cool MJ. Let's not make this more than a QB debate, pls

You got it, Elias, but you're reading the whole thread, are you not?? Really big fan is the one who's attempting to antagonize me here. Then Blindside feels the need to chime in because he's always so hurt by the things I post. I've made it clear many times before, it's not personal. If they do not like the things I post, place me on ignore. I really couldn't care less.