I agree with you but lets remember Geno was completing 70% of his passes in college and Russel Wilson was below 60% his first 3 years of college and his senior year he was much better. Scouts ripped him and said his accuracy was bad because of his size and he wouldn't make it in the NFL.
Both good points on smith and Wilson.
My real problem with the pick is where it was made. I understood Petty's problems coming into the NFL, but in the 4th round I thought he had excellent value from a risk reward standpoint, and he improved much from the senior Bowl to the pre-season Atlanta game where IMO he played very well.
If Hackenberg was selected where Cook was selected, who I liked better, I would also be more excited about the pick. IMO he went to high.
I'm not going to beat up on the kid, I love his natural arm talent, but the 2 years of bad film, and I've watched a lot of Penn St's games, is hard to forget.
For now, I am going to defer to Macc's superior discernment and see if the kid can make the same kind of improvement that Petty did coming into camp. Macc must really love the guy to give of a 2nd for him with the needs the Jets have.
If he's right, IMO the Jets will be in an excellent QB situation moving forward. Particularly if they can get Fitz signed , and "get a bag of rocks" for smith in next years draft