I agree the nod should go to Geno if the competition is even remotely close.
If that's the case, let's pray they both played equally WELL, instead of both stinking up the joint . . .
That was my mentality last year, that if it was remotely close, it goes to Geno. But I think he has lost that right now. He has to legitimately be the best QB to earn the job.
That is why I voted Fitzpatrick.