First on Bradford, I said Locker is not on that level, sorry if I wasn't clear about that, but I agree, Bradford is a legit franchise QB if he stays healthy. He has all of the tools to be franchise QB. Locker is a notch below that in my view, but better than Mallet, Hoyer and Fitz. Again, if we remove durability from the equation and are just talking about talent.I'd rate Foles and Bradford ahead of him in my wish list...by a lot...but just me. Point - whats your opinion on Foles? Im sure ive read it but forgot it.
As for Foles, I don't see him as much better than Locker. Obviously he's way more durable, so all things being equal I'll take Foles over Locker any day of the week, but all things are not equal because Locker is a FA and he would cost us nothing but money, while Foles takes us out of the elite prospect range and IMO he's not good enough to justify trading out of the 6 spot and all the way down to 20, unless we are making a killing.
For a more detailed explanation, here's what I posted in another thread:
I'm dead against trading down with the Eagles and here's why ...
IMO there are 13 elite prospects in this draft if you count the two QB's, Winston and Mariota, and I'll list the 13, by position and in no particular order, so there can be no ambiguity:
QB Marcus Mariota
QB Jameis Winston
WR Kevin White
WR Amari Cooper
WR DeVante Parker
DL Leonard Williams
DT Danny Shelton
DE/OLB Dante Fowler
DE/OLB Shane Ray
DE/OLB Vic Beasley
DE/OLB Randy Gregory
DE/OLB Alvin Dupree
CB Trae Waynes
Thats it, after those guys there's a significant drop-off in my view, therefore if you trade down to 20 you are effectively taking yourself out of the running for one of the elite prospects in this draft, and that only makes sense for me if I believe Nick Foles is a franchise QB or is headed in that direction, and I don't, and neither does Chip Kelly or he wouldn't be looking for another QB, no matter how much he loves Mariota, because you don't trade a young franchise QB for someone you hope or even believe can reach that level.
Also I've done the draft trade value chart math and I know we wouldn't be getting anything even close to what some Jet fans are fantasizing about in draft picks, which is essentially a Hershel WaIker or Ricky Williams deal.
NOT HAPPENING
According to the chart, if you put a second round value on Foles as the Eagles will undoubtedly do, all we would be getting in return after Foles and #20 is their 2nd RD Pick in this draft, and thats it, and even if they throw in their 3 this year or 2 next year, its not enough for me to trade out of the 6 spot and all the way down to 20.
So for me this trade would be a colossal mistake, but if you tell me we're trading down with the Rams to #10 or even Cleveland at #12 , both distinct possibilities, then I'm all ears and listening to offers because that would keep us in the elite prospect range, but I'm not trading down to 20 unless Chip Kelly is prepared to throw the value chart in the garbage and make a mind-numbingly stupid trade from the Eagles perspective.