I would love to have Petty as our QB next year. Lets hope Geno plays well this year!!
man it would be nice to catch lightning in a bottle with this kid..One thing I like about Petty is his ability to throw a real nice ball without a wind up. Just snaps it behind his ear, and it's off. Trait of a lot of good QB's. Think the kid has a chance.
One thing I like about Petty is his ability to throw a real nice ball without a wind up. Just snaps it behind his ear, and it's off. Trait of a lot of good QB's. Think the kid has a chance.
man it would be nice to catch lightning in a bottle with this kid..
if nothing else we are due..
it was ideal to move up a few spots & grab this kid in the 4th round!!Got a good feeling on this kid 13. Didn't want him in the 1st or 2nd. Just to green, and needs some time on the bench. The 4th was a great spot for him. No pressure to play now, great work ethic, very smart.
The best mechanics of any QB in this draft IMO. Liked Winston, but his wind up worries me a lot in the NFL
One thing I like about Petty is his ability to throw a real nice ball without a wind up. Just snaps it behind his ear, and it's off. Trait of a lot of good QB's. Think the kid has a chance.
NEVER as in never, ever or just in his rookie year in the NFL? I just want to be clear on your comment, because he had 98 TDs, 21 INTs and 0 fumbles at West Virginia, with a ridiculous 40+ TDs and 7 INTs his senior year. Granted that was college in a spread offense, and the NFL is night and day to that situation. Just the same, I would hardly characterize that as not taking care of the football. Last year he nearly cut his INTs in half from his rookie year (from 21 to 13), but I'm sure you know that as well.Because if he's anything like Geno Smith then we know he's going to fail everything else. Geno Smith has NEVER been able to take care of the football. By my way of thinking, that makes everything else that he does on the football field IRRELEVANT. If you can't take care of the football you don't belong on the professional level.
And in both years, he ended up ranked at or near the bottom of the NFL quarterbank rankings. And in that marvelous "improved" second year, he managed to "lead" the Jets to 3 wins, 2 of them in the meaningless last 3 games. When it mattered, Mr. "Take care of the football" threw away THREE picks in just one quarter before being mercifully benched.NEVER as in never, ever or just in his rookie year in the NFL? I just want to be clear on your comment, because he had 98 TDs, 21 INTs and 0 fumbles at West Virginia, with a ridiculous 40+ TDs and 7 INTs his senior year. Granted that was college in a spread offense, and the NFL is night and day to that situation. Just the same, I would hardly characterize that as not taking care of the football. Last year he nearly cut his INTs in half from his rookie year (from 21 to 13), but I'm sure you know that as well.
First of all, I was just getting clarification on NE Guy's post. As far as Geno Smith's future goes, all I will say is we'll see because unfortunately my crystal ball is broken.And in both years, he ended up ranked at or near the bottom of the NFL quarterbank rankings. And in that marvelous "improved" second year, he managed to "lead" the Jets to 3 wins, 2 of them in the meaningless last 3 games. When it mattered, Mr. "Take care of the football" threw away THREE picks in just one quarter before being mercifully benched.
The fact is, he stinks, and fortunately Maccagnan was smart enough to recognize this and immediately traded for Ryan Fitzpatrick and drafted Bryce Petty.
Those of us with eyes have seen enough to not want the team we love piss away a third season by running this bust out on the field again. We have seen Browning Nagle, Brooks Bollinger, Neil O Donnell, Mark Sanchez and the rest destroy seasons and get coaches and GMs canned.
Mac and Bowles are too smart to let Geno destroy their management careers
i believe smith is working with a 2 to 3 1/2 game window to keep the starting job..First of all, I was just getting clarification on NE Guy's post. As far as Geno Smith's future goes, all I will say is we'll see because unfortunately my crystal ball is broken.![]()
Agreei believe smith is working with a 2 to 3 1/2 game window to keep the starting job..
but i'm not convinced on him being named the week 1 starter, BTW..
what i can't see happening is bolwes letting smith ruin the season before the bye..Agree
Starts first PS game
Splits time with Fitzpatrick in second
Fitzpatrick named starter for third game and the regular season
And in both years, he ended up ranked at or near the bottom of the NFL quarterbank rankings. And in that marvelous "improved" second year, he managed to "lead" the Jets to 3 wins, 2 of them in the meaningless last 3 games. When it mattered, Mr. "Take care of the football" threw away THREE picks in just one quarter before being mercifully benched.
The fact is, he stinks, and fortunately Maccagnan was smart enough to recognize this and immediately traded for Ryan Fitzpatrick and drafted Bryce Petty.
Those of us with eyes have seen enough to not want the team we love piss away a third season by running this bust out on the field again. We have seen Browning Nagle, Brooks Bollinger, Neil O Donnell, Mark Sanchez and the rest destroy seasons and get coaches and GMs canned.
Mac and Bowles are too smart to let Geno destroy their management careers
Its called a 'quick release' and you're right, its a great quality for a QB to have. Namath and Marino had two of the quickest releases ever, the stuff you described, to the ear and out, no wasted motion.One thing I like about Petty is his ability to throw a real nice ball without a wind up. Just snaps it behind his ear, and it's off. Trait of a lot of good QB's. Think the kid has a chance.
NEVER as in never, ever or just in his rookie year in the NFL? I just want to be clear on your comment, because he had 98 TDs, 21 INTs and 0 fumbles at West Virginia, with a ridiculous 40+ TDs and 7 INTs his senior year. Granted that was college in a spread offense, and the NFL is night and day to that situation. Just the same, I would hardly characterize that as not taking care of the football. Last year he nearly cut his INTs in half from his rookie year (from 21 to 13), but I'm sure you know that as well.
If it makes you feel better to call me a 'spin master', apologist or whatever, have at it. I have watched professional football and followed it very closely for almost 50 years, and I have seen plenty of guys as talented as Smith bust and seen plenty who figure it out and are successful. It's because of that, that I'm not ready to pull the plug on this very talented, young yet undeveloped QB. I've said it before and it bears repeating here; my only loyalty is to the Jets and for them to be successful. If that means RF or BP as the QB, great, but if Smith turns the corner it represents the best situation for the Jets. We have a young inexpensive franchise QB, a solid veteran to come in in case of injury and a talented draftee who can sit, watch and develop at the appropriate pace.We're talking about the pros here, not the minor leagues.:wtf:
And he only cut his interceptions numbers almost in half because he got BENCHED a few times for poor and ineffective play laden with turnovers. Are you just another one of these spin masters on this site? What a crock. Why not tell things like they are rather than make some silly proclamation by splitting hairs?
He's completely reckless with the football, Including several fumbles because he carries the ball like a loaf of bread. He's taken sacks that moved the team out of scoring position more than once. The guy is out of control and hasn't learned a damn thing since his rookie campaign. He cannot read defenses and he cannot make progressions. He's awful and his days are most certainly numbered in NY.