TOJ article - Geno

McJet

Repeat Offender Pro Bowler
Jet Fanatics
if bowles & maccagnan had chosen not to pursue fitzpatrick & handed smith back the job instead?? IMO, they would absolutely have put their job's on the line..

i've run into a small but loud pocket of jet fans online that believe that's what should have happened, BTW..


I agree, but that's not what i'm reading in that last paragraph i was referring to.
The Jets are pursuing Fitzpatrick, they are not just giving him a blank check. They've fixed a certain amount to him and are, as of now, sticking to their guns.
 

jetgreen13

founding JFU member..
Jet Fanatics
I agree, but that's not what i'm reading in that last paragraph i was referring to.
The Jets are pursuing Fitzpatrick, they are not just giving him a blank check. They've fixed a certain amount to him and are, as of now, sticking to their guns.
LOLz i'm a bit confused but i believe for the most part, we are on the same page..
 

BlindsideD'Brick

Franchise Tagged
Jet Fanatics
First off, what's with the caps??? do you think that makes you're point more convincing or that i need help reading smaller words?
Secondly, If the pressure from the media and the fans gets so intense that the Jets up their offer, then personally, i don't want Maccagnan as the GM. He has a conviction and he's sticking to it.That same conviction that got the Jets B. Marshall, R. Clady on a team friendly deal. Mo Wilkerson signed to a contract the Jets can work with. As far as i'm concerned, Maccagnan has performed very well as GM of the Jets. He has, IMO, upgraded every position group on the jets.
The pressure from fans and media wouldn't get intense until the Jets start losing games with Geno. I do not think that Fitzpatrick can sign with this team by week 3, 4 or 5 and be a savior. Not with this schedule the Jets have and you keep pointing out how difficult it is.

Shouting in CAPS makes a person's point more valid. You didn't get the memo? LOL.

I want Fitz back as much as the next fan. But if he's holding out for guaranteed money in the 10-12 million range through years 2-3, he can go sign somewhere else. I'll roll with Geno for 2016, and see what we've got with Hack/Petty in 2017. Fitz was good last year, until he shit the bed up in Buffalo. That was a big game meltdown.
 

Bronx

Repeat Offender Pro Bowler
Jet Fanatics
The Jets have made more than a fair offer, that's obvious. What team on this planet will do better? Please enlighten me


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

McJet

Repeat Offender Pro Bowler
Jet Fanatics
This morning Cimini was on the radio, he and the host were both stating that if Fitzpatrick is not in camp by, they said, the Redskin preseason game Aug. 19th then they have to go all in on Geno. They said it would be unfair to Geno and the rest of the team to have the Fitzpatrick saga hanging over the Jets past that time.
Sorry, i can't remember if it was the Fan or ESPN. It was one of 'em though.
 

TebowCan'tThrow

Supersize!
The Mod Squad
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
This morning Cimini was on the radio, he and the host were both stating that if Fitzpatrick is not in camp by, they said, the Redskin preseason game Aug. 19th then they have to go all in on Geno. They said it would be unfair to Geno and the rest of the team to have the Fitzpatrick saga hanging over the Jets past that time.
Sorry, i can't remember if it was the Fan or ESPN. It was one of 'em though.

I say that is the final deadline, but I start dropping the offer by $2M per week until that deadline.
 

Bronx

Repeat Offender Pro Bowler
Jet Fanatics
Coach Todd Bowles thinks Geno Smith can be the Jets’ starter.
"I think Geno can be a good starter, but he’s got to prove it in training camp like everybody else," Bowles said. "He’s been in the system a year. We’ll see what he does." It’s not more than coachspeak, but the Jets have thrown support behind Smith all offseason. Despite a standstill in contract talks, Ryan Fitzpatrick remains likely to be the Week 1 starter.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
M

Mainejet

Guest
I'm thinking the sbsolute drop dead cut off point should be Juky 27th or 3 days from now. It's time for Fitz to sh*t or get off the pot.
I truly believe that if Fitz doesn't get his butt in camp by August 11, Bowles will roll with Geno


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
M

Mainejet

Guest
Yes it is as a matter of fact, but HOW does that make it wrong? Every single shred of evidence about Geno points to him being an idiot on and off the football field.
Lol. "He sucks and that's that" is not actually an argument of any sort. It is, however, a fair summation of your opinion.
 
M

Mainejet

Guest
I don't disagree with any of this, but HOW does that not make what I just posted, wrong? You said, "Woody is privy to everything Mac does". I responded with, "Woody was privy to everything John Idzik did" and STILL be the fan base signed his own death warrant and Woody LISTENED. So you're wrong in that liner of thinking very clearly. End of subject.
First off, what's with the caps??? do you think that makes you're point more convincing or that i need help reading smaller words?
Secondly, If the pressure from the media and the fans gets so intense that the Jets up their offer, then personally, i don't want Maccagnan as the GM. He has a conviction and he's sticking to it.That same conviction that got the Jets B. Marshall, R. Clady on a team friendly deal. Mo Wilkerson signed to a contract the Jets can work with. As far as i'm concerned, Maccagnan has performed very well as GM of the Jets. He has, IMO, upgraded every position group on the jets.
The pressure from fans and media wouldn't get intense until the Jets start losing games with Geno. I do not think that Fitzpatrick can sign with this team by week 3, 4 or 5 and be a savior. Not with this schedule the Jets have and you keep pointing out how difficult it is.
 
M

Mainejet

Guest
And what about all of the areas where the author points out that Geno SUCKS and BTW it is on;ly the vadst area of responsibility that goes with the job, or does that not fit YOUR narrative?
What about the several sections where he outlines where Geno was better, in some cases much better, than he expected? You ignore them because they don't fit with your narrative.
 

McJet

Repeat Offender Pro Bowler
Jet Fanatics
I don't disagree with any of this, but HOW does that not make what I just posted, wrong? You said, "Woody is privy to everything Mac does". I responded with, "Woody was privy to everything John Idzik did" and STILL be the fan base signed his own death warrant and Woody LISTENED. So you're wrong in that liner of thinking very clearly. End of subject.

Yes,he was privy to it. Idzik was also the only GM that would take the job with Rex Ryan staying on as head coach. Woodys love affair with Rex was a big problem. Then going 8-8 then 4-12 is what did him and Idzik in.
After this season we will see how terrible Idziks drafts were.
Smith, Richardson, Miliner, Reilly, Enunwa,Winters, Miles, McDougle, Pryor, Amaro, Marcus Williams.
We'll see who contributes and who hits the Bricks to actually see how bad his picks were or were they not coached properly to perform at the NFL level. Schottenheimer, Tannenbaum, Sparano, Mornhinweg, Idzik. That's a lot of guys falling on the sword of Rex Ryan. Idziks worst decision was not hiring his own staff and coaches or maybe taking a job that wouldn't allow him to.
Lastly, ARE you TEN years OLD?
 

ReallyBigfan

How Big is Too Big?
Jet Fanatics
I'm thinking the sbsolute drop dead cut off point should be Juky 27th or 3 days from now. It's time for Fitz to sh*t or get off the pot.

I think that if Fitzpatrick does not sign by that date (7/27) or at the latest, within the first few days of training camp, then at the very least there should be a status change. Meaning that if Geno is looking good in camp, which is likely, then even if Fitzpatrick does sign at a later point, he should not simply be handed back the starter's gig, but should have to compete for it against Geno. Maybe Fitz wins that competition, maybe not, but if Geno has been working hard as the number 1 QB all offseason long and into training camp, I think he deserves at least a shot at winning the job for real.
 

TebowCan'tThrow

Supersize!
The Mod Squad
Jet Fanatics
Jets Global
I think that if Fitzpatrick does not sign by that date (7/27) or at the latest, within the first few days of training camp, then at the very least there should be a status change. Meaning that if Geno is looking good in camp, which is likely, then even if Fitzpatrick does sign at a later point, he should not simply be handed back the starter's gig, but should have to compete for it against Geno. Maybe Fitz wins that competition, maybe not, but if Geno has been working hard as the number 1 QB all offseason long and into training camp, I think he deserves at least a shot at winning the job for real.

Regardless of when Fitz signs now, he should have to compete for the job. I don't think Geno is going to be a good QB, but I also know he has never had a chance with good to great talent around him. Maybe he learned a lesson last season and maybe he learned a lot from Fitz.
 

jetgreen13

founding JFU member..
Jet Fanatics
Regardless of when Fitz signs now, he should have to compete for the job. I don't think Geno is going to be a good QB, but I also know he has never had a chance with good to great talent around him. Maybe he learned a lesson last season and maybe he learned a lot from Fitz.
the problem, for me at least, is that there's is almost nothing to learn in training camp & preseason games..

smith has been at least solid at both since his rookie year.. i don't see that changing, do you??

& i just can't see the logic in eventually paying fitzpatrick starting QB money (even if only in year one of the contract) & asking him to win back the job.....
 
M

Mainejet

Guest
Well, I would say you must be 10 years old. You are the one that was proven wrong and yet you need to come back with little, childish digs because you don't have anything to psay in response.
Yes,he was privy to it. Idzik was also the only GM that would take the job with Rex Ryan staying on as head coach. Woodys love affair with Rex was a big problem. Then going 8-8 then 4-12 is what did him and Idzik in.
After this season we will see how terrible Idziks drafts were.
Smith, Richardson, Miliner, Reilly, Enunwa,Winters, Miles, McDougle, Pryor, Amaro, Marcus Williams.
We'll see who contributes and who hits the Bricks to actually see how bad his picks were or were they not coached properly to perform at the NFL level. Schottenheimer, Tannenbaum, Sparano, Mornhinweg, Idzik. That's a lot of guys falling on the sword of Rex Ryan. Idziks worst decision was not hiring his own staff and coaches or maybe taking a job that wouldn't allow him to.
Lastly, ARE you TEN years OLD?
 

NYJETSDAN16

Repeat Offender Pro Bowler
Jet Fanatics
This whole notion of a "Cutoff" point with Fitzpatrick is just ridiculous.

WHy, becuase the Geno fans will be placed back into seclusion for a competentant QB who:

a) Knows the system

b)Has great chemistry with his teammates

c) excellent Locker room leader

d)A figure head to help groom the younger two QB's in Petty and Hack

Honestly, Everyone knows, even this organization knows that Fitz is the best option for this years success. Stop with this none-sense of "Geno never had the weapons Fitz had". He wouldn't know what to do with it any way.

"Oh how dare you say that..It's Hate". If that's considered "hate", then the ones not wanting Fitzpatrick back should be called "Delusional" into thinking we will have a successful year with Geno at the helm.

If Fitz re-signs the Saturday before the Bengals game, the team would roll out a huge red carpet for him knowing that they have a shot of something special this season.

Some Geno fans over look his decision making and try to get away with his potential:

David Klingler
Andre Ware
Eric Zeier
Browning Nagle
Demarcus Russel
Ryan Leaf
Dave Brown
Tim Couch
Tony Banks
All had potential. Though they lacked what Fitz has, something between the ears to play the game. With is the most important part of playing within the white paint on the grass.
 
Last edited:

jetgreen13

founding JFU member..
Jet Fanatics
This whole notion of a "Cutoff" point with Fitzpatrick is just ridiculous.

WHy, becuase the Geno fans will be placed back into seclusion for a competentant QB who:

a) Knows the system

b)Has great chemistry with his teammates

c) excellent Locker room leader

d)A figure head to help groom the younger two QB's in Petty and Hack

Honestly, Everyone knows, even this organization knows that Fitz is the best option for this years success. Stop with this none-sense of "Geno never had the weapons Fitz had". He wouldn't know what to do with it any way.

"Oh how dare you say that..It's Hate". If that's considered "hate", then the ones not wanting Fitzpatrick back should be called "Delusional" into thinking we will have a successful year with Geno at the helm.

If Fitz re-signs the Saturday before the Bengals game, the team would roll out a huge red carpet for him knowing that they have a shot of something special this season.

Some Geno fans over look his decision making and try to get away with his potential:

David Klingler
Andre Ware
Eric Zeier
Browning Nagle
Demarcus Russel
Ryan Leaf
Dave Brown
Tim Couch
Tony Banks
All had potential. Though they lacked what Fitz has, something between the ears to play the game. With is the most important part of playing within the white paint on the grass.
i completely agree the locker room would be thrilled to have fitzpatrick back in the fold, even if was just hours before the season opener..

but i think it's not realistic to think fitzpatrick can roll out of bed sunday morning & be ready for the bengals..

the rest of the post we are pretty much in lockstep.....
 
Top