I'm okay with signing Fitz to a reasonable contract, but not more than $9-10 mil a season, I do not think he is worth more than that. Yes, he was 30/15, but there was a really good film analysis showing that he was lucky that it wasn't reversed (15/30), how he was saved from so many INTs by his exceptional receivers on some really bad passes that he threw, and how he benefited from a very soft schedule. While I am in favor of bringing him back, I am very concerned about a significant regression from him, especially given how difficult this season's schedule is projected to be compared to last.
And your Geno-hating is irrational,
a complete double-standard. I love Petty, but everyone has emphasized and accepted how he unquestionably would need time to develop since he played in a spread offense in college, not a pro-style system at all. Guess what? Geno had the same situation, coming from a spread offense in college, but he was never given the time to develop in the pros, he was a starter from game 1 - but the haters never cut him any slack for that, never understand that he was thrust into the fire with no chance to sit and learn the pro game while playing behind an experienced QB, so of course he was going to make what appeared to be dumb mistakes. He had some terrible games but he also had some great games, even if the haters want to pretend that he didn't. Go back and look at his game against the Pats in October 2014 as a case in point. He gave the Jets a chance to win on the last play - thwarted by a blocked FG, but he gave them a chance against one of the best teams in the league and an intense rival. Over the last SIX weeks of the 2014 season his improvement was clear to see for any fair-minded person; he completed almost 66% of his passes, a dramatic improvement in his accuracy, and his QB rating over those last six weeks was top-ten in the league. Six weeks is not one flukey game, it is a significant stretch. And he capped it with
the only perfect QB rating game by any QB during the 2014 season in the finale vs the Fins. And please stop with the blithering nonsense that the Dolphins didn't care about winning the game; they had a chance to finish at .500, they wanted to try to save their coach's job, and the Jets are a hated divisional rival. Of course they cared a great deal about winning the game, but Geno played a great game. So your insistence that Geno, working with far better weapons than he ever had before, and a great OC in Gailey, and coming off the best six game stretch of his young career, AND having an easier schedule than ever before, couldn't possibly have had as good a season as Fitzpatrick did in 2015, is based on pure hating, not reason.
Here is an article from CBS Sports (from last off-season) that supports what I am saying:
http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/writer...hy-jets-are-smart-not-to-scrap-geno-smith-yet
Read the whole article, he brings very specific indications of Geno's improvements as an NFL QB, including working through his progressions, making adjustments based on what the defense shows, etc.