Yet Neil O'Donnell led the Steelers to an (11-5) season in 1995, and only lost in the Super Bowl to the dynastic DAL team of the early 90s in their final hurrah.
HYATT™ is no O'Donnell apologist, never liked his WAY TOO conservative brand of football - but as with Brad Johnson in Trampa, Trent Dilfer in his later years in BAL, Doug Williams in WAS, Len Dawson in KC, Earl Morrall in Indy, Craig Morton in DAL & DEN, Bob Griese & David Woodley in MIA, Troy Aikman in DAL, Rich Gannon in OAK, & Matt Hasselbeck in SEA - you CAN get to and even win a Super Bowl with a less than dynamic QB taking snaps, if you have the supporting cast surrounding him to hold down the other team's ability to be more dynamic.
Odds are higher you'll end up with the short end of the stick more often than not, but it IS possible.
It's just a whole lot EASIER if your QB is a playmaker like Favre, Elway, Eli, Montana, Young, Roethlisberger, Rodgers, Kelly, Stabler, or Bradshaw - and you still have the dynamic surrounding cast too.
Nothing is guaranteed in writing of course, but HYATT™ suspects the Jills fans are happier about losing 4 consecutive Super Bowls with Kelly than Chiefs fans are for having won only 1, way back in 1970, with Len Dawson.
Fitzpatrick CAN be a stable enough QB to get the Jets to the Big Dance, with a lot of help from his team, & HYATT™ doesn't know if you can ask any more of a QB than that.
Ultimately it IS a "team sport", and QBs don't win Lombardis all by themselves.
Never have and never will.
Kreist, that tool in New England is more than proof of that concept - 3 trophies courtesy of a damn KICKER & a fourth courtesy of an undrafted rookie DB, (or a SEA HC who outsmarted himself).